Month: May 2014

ONE of the biggest shocks of the local elections in Clare occurred on Sunday night when Fine Gael’s Oliver Garry lost his seat on Clare County Council.

The Kildysert man lost out in the race for the final three seats in West Clare after being knocked out on the 11th count.

The disappointment was writ large on Garry’s face at the end of a long day and night in the West County Hotel.

But the experienced politician was taking defeat in his stride.

“I feel disappointed but I’ve gone though worse in life. Losing an election is not the worst thing in the world. We have to get up and get on with life again. Tomorrow I’ll be in a different scene. I’ll be involved in some other project in life. That’s what it’s all about. Losing an election isn’t the end of the world for me,” he said.

Flanked by family and supporters, including Fine Gael TD Pat Breen, Garry recalled the drama of a marathon count.

“I was feeling very

confident during the

day, especially after

last night’s disappoint

ment when my tally

was only 990 and we

found 240 more votes.

I was confident today

but obviously it went

down to who went out

first and where the

transfers were going

to go. They came to

Gabriel (Keating) and

I’d like to congratulate

Gabriel as well.”

He continued, “At least they have a seat in the west, in the Loop, which is important as well. We’re probably without a seat now in the south of the county which is probably a bit disappointing.”

THERE will be seven new members in the Clare County Council chamber when they meet for the first time on June 6, although one among them, Tony O’Brien, will have served there before.

The Fianna Fáil candidate lost his seat in Killaloe in 2009, but claimed it back on the seventh count with a surplus of 182.

Also coming in on that seventh count was newbie Alan O’Callaghan for Fianna Fáil, who came in ahead of running mate and son of a former county councillor, Liam Wiley, who failed to be elected.

Held high in Treacys West County Hotel at 1.30am on Sunday morning, the Kilmurry man was delighted with his success.

He attributed his win to a strong campaign and a lot of support from family and friends.

A relaxed character, he is undaunted by the size of the Killaloe Electoral Area or his journey into the unknown that is local politics.

“I would be a very positive person and like that; I wouldn’t let anything phase me. I love taking on problems and issues. I love keeping people on the straight and narrow, keeping people informed of what ever they need to do,” said the self employed East Clare man.

So what is he looking forward to now that he has been elected to Clare County Council?

“First of all I am looking forward to meeting my wife, I haven’t seen her in the last four months. Then we’ll get tomorrow out of the way, sit down on Monday and wire into it then,” he said minutes after being elected.

The rest of the new faces include three former town councillors – Mary Howard FG in Ennis, Mike McKee SF in Shannon and Ian Lynch Ind in West Clare.

Also in the line up of new candidates are Independent candidate Ann Norton and Fianna Fáil candidate Clare Colleran Molloy FF.

WHAT are three votes between neighbours? Well, a lot when there is a Clare County Council seat at stake.

That was the reality that faced Fine Gael’s Ger O’Halloran when his neighbour, friend and political foe Clare Colleran Molloy from Fianna Fáil came from behind in the very last count to take the last seat in the Ennis Electoral Area.

On the 19th count there were five candidates remaining to take the last four seats.

O’Halloran was ahead of Colleran Molloy by 11 votes and positioned to take the seat.

However, Ann Norton, who was elected in the 18th count, still had a surplus to divide among the candidates and this brought in Colleran Molloy ahead of O’Halloran.

Norton’s transfer ensured the woman from Quin was ahead of her neighbour by three votes.

Following a mammoth count of the election area with the most candidates in the country, a recount was called.

Hours later both candidates were called to meet with returning officer Michael McNamara, as the crowd watched on.

He informed them that after the recount there was now five votes be- tween them and Ms Colleran Molloy was deemed elected.

There was devastation among O’Halloran’s supporters, and jubilation from those that lived just a few miles away.

A giant of a man, Ger O’Halloran, battled to keep his own emotions in check as he consoled family, friends and supporters.

“We were both from the Quin area and the association between the O’Hallorans and the Collerans goes back generations,” he told the media, describing Clare as “a very wonderful political foe”.

“But I want our families association to continue. You couldn’t make it up,” he said.

“My transfers as it all unfolded were very disappointing. At times I needed to open a little gap to feel more comfortable, but I could feel this dripping away from me. It never ran away from me. It drifted away from me. And ultimately it came down to the one last transfer of votes.

“You just couldn’t make this up as I said. How it has unfolded has added to the drama here in over the last two days,” he added, summing up the political spectacle.

While Mr O’Halloran said it was too soon to say for definite if he would contest another election, his wife Ciara and supporters were quick to say, he would be ready in five years time.

A NUMBER of North Clare tourism developments, which appeared to have fallen victim of the recession, could be kick-started in the months ahead following a raft of planning application lodged with Clare County Council over the past week.

Lazarus Investment Limited have lodged four separate application in the past week which could create hundreds of construction jobs and scores of permanent permission if they go ahead.

Each of the application involve an extension of the planning duration of projects originally proposed by the Atlantis Development Company.

Indeed, according to documents obtained from the Company Registration Office (CRO), local businessman John Declan Flanagan, with a company address at ‘The Mermaid’ in Liscannor, is the director of both Lazarus Investment Limited and the Atlantis Development Company.

The first application could see a major redevelopment of two of North Clare’s most iconic pubs – Egan’s and McHugh’s in Liscannor. The application for extension, which was the first made by Lazarus in April of this year, could see major alterations to existing structures located between the pubs.

It involves the demolition of a storage area and toilets at the back of Joseph McHugh’s and a storage buildings at the back of Egan’s and the extension of McHugh including a new storage area, lounge, toilets and an open smoking area. The development will also see the construction of a seven bedroom hostel, five apartments and four commercial units.

The second application involved outline permission for the development a supermarket, crèche, medical centre and a chemist. The site, which is located at Killilagh in Doolin, will also include the construction of five houses.

The third application involved the construction of 11 houses at Teergonean in Doolin. The original planning permission, which was for two three-bedroom houses as well as nine two-bedroom self catering units, was granted planning permission by Clare County Council in 2008.

The fourth application will see the construction of a park and ride facility connecting Liscannor with the Cliffs of Moher.

Separate decision on the retention of the planning permissions will be made on various dates from June of this year.

A HOME-MADE knife was discovered in the entrance at Ennis Courthouse following a number of scuffles that broke out on Wednesday.

Gardaí are investigating altercations which flared up between members of two families who were present in the courthouse on the day.

A fight between younger members of both families developed at the entrance at around 11am.

The courthouse was busy with sittings of Ennis District Court and the High Court underway.

People standing in the lobby area initially thought the parties were “messing about” but the incident turned serious when a male teenager was knocked to the floor and struck a number of times.

There was a large number of gardaí present inside the district court positioned between the families who were sat at opposite sides of the courtroom.

Men from either side traded verbal insults. At one point, Judge Patrick Durcan said he would adjourn court business if peace was not kept in the courtroom.

Judge Durcan said law and order was not being maintained in the courtroom and said decent citizens who had business in court were being subjected to “vile behaviour”.

Order was restored both inside and outside the courtroom. A number of people were arrested.

The knife was discovered on the floor just inside the front door at around 11.30am.

It is described as home-made, with two short blades sitting on a handle wrapped in red tape.

Gardaí are investigating the incident and are studying CCTV footage taken from cameras in the Courthouse.

The two Ennis families suspected of being involved in the fracas have been engaged in a dispute for much of the past 12 months.

This is the first violent incident to occur in Ennis Courthouse in recent months.

The building was the scene of a spate of similar fights and altercations throughout 2012 and 2013.

Last October Ennis-based solicitor Daragh Hassett told the court there were times during the year when legal practitioners feared for their safety such was the frequency of fights at the time.

FR TOM McNamara, the priest identified as “Father A” in last week’s review of safeguarding practices in the Diocese of Killaloe, may have abused children in America before returning to the diocese in the late 1960s.

Reports of three separate allegations of abuse involving Fr McNamara have emerged.

These reports involve separate allegation made by adolescents in the Diocese of St Augustine in north Florida where the Clare priests was stationed on dates between 1966 and 1968.

The diocese, which is located near Jacksonville in north Florida, say it was not aware of any subsequent abuse carried out by Fr McNamara until after the priest’s death in 1997.

A report by the Diocese of St Augustine undertaken in 2004 identifies Fr McNamara as the priest accused of “inappropriately touching” three youths during his service as a visiting priest in diocese in the late 1960s.

At the time of the report, a spokes- person from Diocese of St Augustine, which represents 162,000 Catholics, said there was no indication that diocesan officials knowingly returned the priest to an unsuspecting Irish church.

Indeed, according to the report, officials in the diocese only became aware of the allegations in 2003 six years after the death of Fr McNamara.

According to reports, McNamara served as a visiting priest at Christ the King and St Patrick parishes in Jacksonville. It is not clear if the allegation were made by boys or girls – or if the alleged abuse took place on church grounds.

The Bishop of Killaloe, Kieran O’Reilly, last week says he regrets the actions taken by the diocese, which allowed Fr McNamara to remain in active ministry for more than three decades, despite allegations of sexual abuse being made against him.

At the time of the initial abuse, Fr McNamara was not removed from active ministry but was instead sent by the diocese for therapy.

Fr McNamara retired from active minister in 1993 and died in 1997, aged 77.

Patrick (Brud) SKEHAN
, Faheymore, Bridgetown. Peacefully in the Millbrae Lodge Nursing Home, Newport. Removal fromhis residence on Tuesday for 11.30amRequiemMass in Bridgetown church. Burial afterwards in the adjoining cemetery. May he rest in peace.

Bridget (Pydge) STACK (née McNama
ra) , Deerpark, Newmarket-on-Fergus. Formerly of Glin, Co Limerick. RequiemMass in Sixmilebridge Parish Church today (Tuesday) at 12.30pm, followed by burial in Killeen Cemetery. May she rest in peace.

Michael O’BRIEN
, 8 Summerhill, Ennis. Laid to rest in Drumcliffe Cemetery. Donations, if desired, to the Clare 250 Mile Cycle. May he rest in peace.

PJ GINNANE
, Quay Road and formerly of Horse Island, Kildysart, Clare. Peacefully at his residence. Laid to rest in Kildysart. May he rest in peace.

Kieran MCNAMARA
, Portobello, Dublin/Kilkishen, late of Enagh East, Kilkishen. Laid to rest in Clonlea Cemetery. May he rest in peace.

James (Jimmy) RYNNE
, Ballykeale, Kilfenora. Peacefully. Laid to rest in Kilfenora cemetery. May he rest in peace.

Marie CLANCY (née McDonagh)
, Kilnaboy Road, Corofin, formerly of Glasha, Doolin. Laid to rest inThe Holy Rosary Cemetery, Doolin. Donations, if desired, toThe Irish Cancer Society Night Nurse Fund. May she rest in peace.

Patrick DILLON
, Muckinish, Ballyvaughan. Pecefully after a short illness. Laid to rest in Bishopsquarters Cemetery. May he rest in peace.

Kathleen KELLY (née Phelan)
, Rock Bungalow, Old Gort Road, Ennis. Peacefully at the University Hospital Limerick. Laid to rest in Drumcliffe Cemetery. May she rest in peace.

Jane O’SHEA (née Sutton)
, Darragh, Ennis. Laid to rest in Ballyea. Donations, if desired, to Milford Hospice. May she rest in peace.

Hugh RICE
,Attyterilla, Ruan. Peacefully at Milford Hospice Limerick after a short illness. Laid to rest in Ruan Cemetery. Donations, if desired, to Milford Hospice. May he rest in peace

Eamon LEAHY
, 48 Cronin Park, Shannon. Laid to rest in Illaunamanagh Cemetery. May he rest in peace.

Tony LYNCH
, Lissycasey. Peacefully at Cahercalla Hospice. Laid to rest in Lissycasey. Donations if desired toWest Clare Cancer Support and Cahercalla Hospice. May he rest in peace.

Martin QUEALLY,
Meelick, Inagh. Laid to rest in Inagh. Donations, if desired, to Milford Hospice. May he rest in peace.

Michael ROUGHAN
, Ennis, Galway. Formerly of Ballyneylon, Fountain. Laid to rest in the new Cemetery,Athenry. May he rest in peace.

FRESH allegations of historic clerical sexual abuse in the Killaloe Diocese have emerged in the wake of the publication of a review of safeguarding practices by Bishop Kieran O’Reilly last week.

The report, which was undertaken by the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church of Ireland, details 26 separate allegation made against one priest, identified in the report as “Father A”, which took place on various dates from the mid-60s to the 1990s.

The priest was subsequently identified by Bishop O’Reilly as Fr Tom McNamara, who passed away in 1997.

Since this information was made public last Tuesday, The Clare People has been contacted by a number of people who claim to have been abused by Father McNamara – including one man who alleges that the abuse he suffered was not part of the 26 cases identified in the report.

The man, who has asked not to be identified, claims to have been abused by Father McNamara in an East Clare primary school in the mid to late 1960s.

“He abused me when I was at school. He would line up the boys against the school wall and put his hands inside their trousers. I would have been 12 years-old at the time. He would bring us to matches and no-one would want to sit in the front seat,” said the man.

“It wasn’t hidden at all. Everyone knew about it. What I don’t understand is why the teacher didn’t do anything. She [the teacher who is now deceased] must have known what was going on and did nothing. There was never a formal complaint made. Sure who would I complain to?”

Despite this alleged abuse, the man has a positive outlook towards members of the local church, and Bishop Emeritus Willie Walsh in particular. The man met Bishop Walsh during his time at St Flannan’s School in Ennis and described as “an honorable man, a decent man that you could say something to”.

Current child protection procedures at the Diocese of Killaloe was commended as part of last week’s report. Both current Bishop Kieran O’Reilly and his predecessor Willie Walsh were commended by the report for their handling of allegation made in the diocese and the steps they have taken to improve child safety in the diocese.

The diocese of Killaloe has designated two people, Cleo Yates and Fr Pat Malone, to receive all historic and new reports of abuse. Their contact information is available on www.killaloediocese.ie.

TWO Limerick men appeared before a special sitting of Ennis District Court yesterday charged in connection with thefts from cars in Clare GAA grounds on Sunday.

Jonathan McCarthy (23), with and address at Quarry Road, Thomondgate, Limerick and Samuel Quilligan (25), with an address Altamira, Thomondgate, Limerick, are accused of stealing a hurley and € 20 from a car in Sixmilebridge GAA club on May 18.

They are also charged with the theft of a crate of Smirnoff Ice from a car in Broadford GAA club on May 18.

Mr McCarthy is accused of causing criminal damage to a side window of a car in Kildooras, Clonlara on the same day.

Detective Garda John Mulvihill of Killaloe Garda Station gave evidence of the arrest, charge and caution of Mr McCarthy.

He said in response to two charges, the accused replied, “I’m very sorry”. In reply to the other charge, Mr McCarthy said, “I’m very sorry. I will pay for the costs”.

Detective Garda Bernard Casey of Killaloe Garda Station told the court Mr Quilligan made no comment to charges after caution.

Both men were granted bail subject to a number of conditions.

They were ordered to reside at their addresses; observe a curfew between 11pm and 7am and be available for inspection to gardaí.

They were ordered not to drive any motor vehicles until the case is resolved.

Both men were also ordered to stay out of Clare except for court business. Solicitor for both accused, John Herbert, told the court Mr McCarthy intends to receive immediate psychiatric treatment.

Judge Mary Larkin said Mr McCarthy must notify gardaí of any change in his address.

Both men were assigned legal aid after Mr Herbert said they were suitable candidates.

A third person, Danika Frahill (22) also appeared before the court.

Ms Frahill, with an address at Caherdavin Shopping Centre Apartments, Limerick, is charged with handling a stolen Nokia mobile phone at Shannon Garda Station on May 18. Detective Garda Stephen Ryan of Shannon Garda Station said Ms Frahill made no reply to charge after caution.

Ms Herbert told Judge Larkin that Ms Frahill is presently out of work and a suitable candidate for legal aid. The accused was granted bail on the same conditions as Mr Quilligan and Mr McCarthy.

All three were remanded on bail to appear at Killaloe District Court on July 1 for DPP’s directions.

A CLARE man has appeared in court charged with sexually assaulting a girl in the county just over a year ago.

The alleged offences are alleged to have occurred at a named address in South Clare.

The 39-year-old man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, is charged with five counts of sexual assault of the female on dates unknown between December 1, 2012 and January 2, 2013.

The alleged offences are contrary to section two of the criminal law rape amendment act as amended by section 37 of the sex offender’s act 2001. A schedule of the evidence of arrest, charge and caution of the accused was handed into court by Insp Tom Kennedy.

Defence solicitor Oonagh Moylan made an application for legal aid. However she said this was not a normal application.

She said her client is a factory worker but has debts of € 17,000.

Ms Moylan said the case could require the services of both junior counsel and senior counsel.

She said the legal aid application was an appropriate one given the serious nature of the charges her client is facing. She said her client had filled out a statement of means.

Inspector Tom Kennedy said the State had no objection to legal aid.

He said the case would proceed on a book of evidence to a higher court and that senior counsel may ultimately be engaged.

Judge Durcan granted legal aid.

He also imposed reporting restrictions. Judge Durcan ordered that the name of the accused, the alleged victim and the location of the alleged offences not be published.

He said the media could say the accused is from Clare and could also refer to the general geographical area where the offences are alleged to have occurred. THE case of three people charged following an altercation outside a pub in the Parnell Street area of Ennis last year is due to be heard on October. Solicitors for Kevin Cooper (52), Terry Sherlock (26) and Martin Sherlock (27) told Ennis District Court on Wednesday that a date for hearing would be required. The case, which involves allegations of assault and public order offences, is expected to take three hours to hear. Mr Cooper, with an address at Drumcairnmore, Loughville, Ennis is facing a charge of assault causing harm arising out of an alleged incident near Barcode Bar on March 31, 2013. Martin Sherlock, with an address at Clancy Park, Ennis, is charged with assaulting Mr Cooper arising out of the same circumstances. It is also alleged Martin Sherlock engaged in threatening, abusive and or insulting behaviour at Parnell Street on March 31. Another man Terry Sherlock with an address at Westbourne Watery Road, Ennis is charged with assaulting Mr Cooper at Parnell Street, Ennis on March 31. On Wednesday, solicitor for Mr Cooper, Stephen Nicholas told the court the case involves lengthy CCTV footage. Inspector Tom Kennedy said seven witnesses may be called to give evidence. The court heard the case could take three hours to hear. Judge Patrick Durcan set October 28 as the date for hearing.

A CAR enthusiast who punched a business sign and verbally abused gardaí after his vehicle was seized in Ennis has escaped a prison sentence.

Shane O’Sullivan (23) was instead ordered to carry out 75 hours of community service in lieu of six weeks in prison.

At Ennis District Court on Tuesday, Judge Patrick Durcan said Mr O’Sullivan behaved in a “contemptible manner” towards members of the force after being stopped on the Quin Road on May 17, 2013.

The seizure occurred minutes after another car was taken by gardaí from Mr O’Sullivan who had been driving in an enclosed area of an industrial estate.

Garda Liza McDonagh told the court she stopped Mr O’Sullivan’s vehicle on the Quin Road at around 22.54pm because it was in very poor order.

A Garda PSV report subsequently found the car to be defective with problems including three bald tyres and no audible warning device.

Garda McDonagh said that after informing Mr O’Sullivan she was seizing his car, he replied “This is my f*****g car”.

After punching a nearby sign, Mr O’Sullivan told Garda McDonagh and her colleague to go “f*** themselves”, the court heard.

Mr O’Sullivan, with an address at Rockmount Cross, Kilrush Road, Ennis, pleaded guilty to charges of driving a dangerously defective vehicle and engaging in behaviour with intent to provoke a breach of the peace.

His solicitor told the court his client’s behaviour was more in frustration with himself after having two cars seized within a matter of minutes.

The solicitor said his client initially bought the defective car to sell it. He said the vehicle had been booked in for its National Car Test (NCT).

The court heard Mr O’Sullivan comes from a well-known family in the motor trade and intends studying mechanical engineering.

His solicitor said Mr O’Sullivan “behaved outrageously” and subsequently apologised to gardaí.

Judge Durcan asked Garda McDonagh if the apology was genuine. Judge Durcan said that going by Garda McDonagh’s response, Mr O’Sullivan’s had given a “mealy mouthed apology”. Garda McDonagh agreed he had.

The court heard the accused has two previous convictions for road traffic offences and has not come to garda attention since the incident.

Judge Durcan said he regarded this as a “serious offence”. He said Mr O’Sullivan used “foul and filthy language” to gardaí who had just seized his “rattletrap”.

He imposed a € 300 fine and ordered Mr O’Sullivan to complete 75 hours community service in lieu of six weeks in prison.

“Hopefully working for the community he will realise he has to keep his temper under control”. The Judge said.

Judge Durcan said he was also disqualifying Mr O’Sullivan from holding a driver’s license for three months, by way of ancillary order.

However after noting the pleas submitted in mitigation and Mr O’Sullivan’s intentions to work in the motor trade, Judge Durcan vacated the order and did not disqualify him from driving.