This article is from page 9 of the 2014-11-18 edition of The Clare People. OCR mistakes are to be expected so download the original SWF or the rendered page 9 JPG
A MAN has been ordered to pay a contribution to charity after pleading guilty to assault at Ennis Courthouse last month.
Ennis District Court was forced to rise shortly after 1.30pm on October 1 when two men became involved in a row at the entrance to the courtroom. John Doherty (51) was arrested and later brought before Ennis District Court where he was charged with assault and engaging in behaviour with intent to provoke a breach of the peace.
Mr Doherty, who previously lived in Ennis but now has an address at Belcamp Lane, Coolock, Dublin, appeared before Ennis District Court again on Wednesday where he pleaded guilty to assault. The breach of the peace charge against Mr Doherty was struck out following an application from the State.
Inspector Tom Kennedy told the court Mr Doherty encountered Michael McDonagh at the entrance to the courtroom and words were exchanged between them.
He said an altercation developed outside the courtroom. He said Mr Doherty threw a number of punches at Mr McDonagh, leaving him with a bruised and swollen face,
Judge Patrick Durcan remarked, “So Inspector, there was a little Punch and Judy show outside?”
Defence solicitor John Casey said his client would say he was provoked on the day. He said a “deep insult” was directed at Mr Doherty as he left the courtroom. Mr Casey said there was a dispute between the families but Mr Doherty had kept out of it.
Mr Casey said his client suffered “horrif c injuries” when he was as saulted in Ennis a few years ago. In 2012, Mr Doherty suffered multiple slash wounds when he was the victim of a vicious knife attack at the Maid of Eireann roundabout.
Mr Casey said his client has suffered from post traumatic stress disorder since the attack and had been forced to leave Ennis because of diff culties that emerged at his housing site. Mr Casey told the court Mr Doherty suffered the loss of his teenage son after he was stabbed in Ennis in 2007. A 19-year-old Ennis man was subsequently convicted of the manslaughter of Michael Doherty (14). The court heard Mr Doherty has two previous convictions for public order offences. In the witness box, John Doherty apologised for his behaviour on the day. “I want to apologise to the court. It shouldn’t have happened.”
Judge Durcan said he accepted the apology. He said Mr Doherty “overacted” but he did not want to give the person who insulted Mr Doherty “an additional scalp” by imposing a criminal conviction.
But Judge Durcan added that the dignity of the court had to be maintained and law and order has to be maintained. Noting the accused’s age, previous good record, the diff culties Mr Doherty has overcome and his commitment to his family, Judge Durcan ordered him to pay € 250 to the court poor box.