Category: News

NEW figures show that since 2009 Clare County Council has issued 201 statutory notices instructing the removal of temporary dwellings from unauthorised encampments around the county. The figures, contained in a new report on Traveller accommodation in Clare, come as communities express frustration with Traveller encampments in areas of Ennis and Barefield.

11 caravans were parked between Barefield village and a section of road leading onto the M18 on Thursday. A spokesman for local residents said there had been a build of rubbish in the area over the past week. “We’ve been absolutely pestered. We don’t deserve that. We’re trying to keep the village tidy. We heard from the council that they got something like 45 calls about this. It seems that there is one law for Travellers and one law for the rest of us.”

According to the spokesman, temporary dwellings can be removed from the side of the road under the local government sanitary services act; the planning and development act and the road traffic act.

Councillors also expressed concern over developments at Barefield at yesterday’s meeting of Clare County Council. Cllr James Breen (Ind) said action needed to be taken to prevent caravans parking at the side of the road.

The meeting also heard that resi- dents of Fioruisce on the Gort Road in Ennis are concerned after four caravans moved into the area over the past month. Cllr Johnny Flynn (FG) said children are at risk by dogs and speeding cars while an area of the housing estate was being used as a “toilet”. Cllr Brennan said it was time for the council to act and to get rid of the caravans.

According to a report prepared by Bernadette Kinsella, Director of Housing, Social and Cultural Services, 201 statutory notices instructing the removal of temporary dwellings from unauthorised encampments were issued in the past two years.

The report explains, “In most cases, the occupiers of the temporary dwellings were previously accommodated by this council or another housing authority and/or they have refused offers of accommodation. There are currently five unauthorised roadside encampments being addressed.”

In relation to the existing legislation, the report states, “In the course of implementing the legislative framework on unauthorised encampments the council has identified some weaknesses in the provisions which need to be addressed. These issues were recently highlighted to the Clare Oireachtas members and have also been referred by the council to the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government with a view to securing a review and revision of the roads and housing legislative provisions.”

CLARE has emerged as the county to lose out in a government costcutting plan that has seen Minister for Education Ruáiri Quinn implement a radical restructuring of the Vocational Education Committees around the country.

On Tuesday, Minister Quinn announced that the county’s VEC headquarters at Station Road in Ennis is to close as part of merger of VECs in Clare, Limerick City and County.

As part of this new blueprint for the administration of vocational education around the country, which was first mooted by the Fianna Fáil/ Greens coalition, Limerick City has been chosen as the new headquarters for the mid-west.

The slashing cuts across the sector are being achieved through the amalgamation of existing VECs bringing the total number from 33 to 16.

Hopes were high a sub-office of the VEC would be maintained in the county capital, but Minister Quinn has confirmed that this would not be the case.

This decision has been made, despite local Fine Gael TD Pat Breen claiming that “the retention of a sub-office in Ennis would be costneutral because the Department of Education owns the building in Ennis”.

Concluding he said that “County Clare always seems to be the poor relation when decisions on regional services are being made. We have already lost our accident and emergency service and our Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food office to Limerick and now we are about to lose our VEC office.”

Minister of State Ciaran Cannon, said that “the main purpose of the VEC rationalisation is to bring about greater efficiencies” and in that regard he said that “the optimum headquarters location for the new merged VEC is within the greater city of Limerick area”.

However, Minister Cannon agreed that in the short-term a sub-office in Ennis will be maintained in order to facilitate an “orderly merger”.

GARDAÍ say an investigation is ongoing into the armed robbery of the Bank of Ireland in Kilkee on Thursday afternoon and say that several people were involved in the incident.

Two men arrested in connection with the incident were released without charge on Saturday night. The two, aged 26 and 31 – who are from west Clare – were arrested in the Doonbeg area on Thursday night, just hours after the incident which took place shortly after 2pm.

During the incident, one man stood at the door of the bank carrying a sawn-off shotgun while another as- sailant threatened staff with a knife.

More than € 8, 500 in cash – including some £2,000 in sterling – was stolen by the gang. No shots were fired and nobody was injured. There was one customer in the bank at the time.

The two arrived at the bank on a high-powered motorbike and travelled along the side of the O’Curry Street premises before entering the building. They made their getaway on the same vehicle.

Members of the Regional Armed Support Unit – which is based in Galway – were called in to assist gardaí in the investigation and gardaí say every effort will be made to solve the crime.

Gardaí have recovered most of the cash stolen, along with a motorcyle and helmets but have not yet located the weapons.

“A file will be sent to the DPP in relation to this,” said a senior garda spokesman. “We believe that there were a number of people involved in planning and implementing this. Our investigations are continuing.

“We have made very substantial progress in it. We are appealing for members of the public who were in the area before, during and after this incident to contact us,” he added.

“We have video footage. One of the men was wearing a green jacket. There might have been a rugby world cup logo on it, and he had white gloves. “The other had a grey jacket and black woollen gloves,” he said.

Gardaí say that the incident is isolated in that it is “completely unrelated” from recent incidents in which burglaries have been carried out in east Clare and Ennis.

The head of the Clare Garda Division Chief Superintendent John Kerin praised gardaí involved in the investigation of this crime.

“I am very pleased with the very proactive and professional response by gardaí, who were assisted by the Divisional and Regional Units,” said Chief Supt Kerin.

IN ECHOING the famous words of WT Cosgrave at the opening of the Shannon Scheme in 1929 when he said “our most famous river will harnessed to the service of the nation”, Clare County Manager Tom Coughlan has said that the Shannon Estuary has a key part to play in Ireland’s economic recovery.

He made his comments this week when announcing the commencement of public consultation on an innovative new Strategic Plan for the Shannon Estuary.

“This is a very exciting initiative for the Shannon Estuary and for the counties of Clare, Limerick and Ker ry as for the first time we are developing a single Strategic Plan for the whole Shannon Estuary including the lands immediately adjacent to the estuary,” Mr Coughlan said.

“It will identify the nature and location of future development on the estuary and allow us harness its potential to a greater degree. I would encourage interested parties to make a submission,” the county manager, who is chairman of the steering group overseeing the plan, added.

The Shannon Estuary is the largest estuary in Ireland with some 500km2 of navigable water running from Kerry Head and Loop Head as far as Limerick City.

The estuary with its sheltered character is Ireland’s premier deepwater port, routinely catering for ships up to 200,000 deadweight tonnage, with key ports at Limerick and Foynes. The estuary supports a variety of economic uses but is also rich in natural resources, wildlife and ecosystems.

“The aim of the Strategic Integrated Framework Plan (SIFP) is to identify the nature and location of future development, economic growth and employment that can be sustainably accommodated within the Shannon Estuary,” said senior Clare County Council planner Gordon Daly.

“Such developments may include, but are not limited to: port functions, shipment, aquaculture/mariculture, fisheries, tourism, leisure, industry, energy generation, fuel storage, aviation, transportation and agriculture,” he added.

However, as the estuary is home to a number of environmentally sensitive sites, Mr Daly has cautioned that new blueprint for the estuary “will also aspire to achieving a careful balance between promoting development, and protection and conservation of this natural resource”.

The strategy is being funded by the local authorities in addition to Shannon Foynes Port Company and Shannon Development. Shannon Foynes Port Company is responsible for all maritime activities and port management on the estuary and is currently in the process of preparing a master plan for the Port of Foynes and Limerick Docks which will input into the preparation of the SIFP.

In addition to the local authori- ties and Shannon Development and Shannon Foynes Port Company the steering group comprises of representatives from the Mid West Regional Authority, Department of Environment, Community and Local Government, Shannon Airport, Clare/Limerick Energy Agency, OPW, National Parks & Wildlife Service, National Monuments Service, OPW, Shannon River Basin District Project, Marine Institute and the Environmental Protection Agency.

A Public Notice has been published to encourage stakeholders, interested parties and the general public to get involved and to bring forward proposals and ideas which will help shape the production of the SIFP.

FOLLOWING on the launch of a government initiative called the ‘The Gathering’ to bring over 300,000 tourists to Ireland in 2013, a West Clare councillor has launched his own plan boost tourist numbers into the county.

At Monday’s meeting of Clare County Council, Cllr Gabriel Keating said his plan “to fly UK tourists for free into Shannon Airport with Aer Lingus on a pilot basis during off peak periods” would represent “a massive off-season boost for Clare tourism”.

Cllr Keating’s plan is that March 19, 2012, to April 16, 2012, and again from September 17, 2012, to October 15, 2012, visitors from the UK would be able to avail of free flights on Aer Lingus routes into Shannon Airport.

“The introduction of this scheme,” Cllr Keating said “would provide a much needed off season boost for our hotels, B&Bs, car rental industry, restaurants, pubs and tourism provider’s right across the county.

“Given the success that the reduction in the VAT rate has had in our hospitality sectors and the genuine efforts by our tourism providers to provide value for money, this initia- tive would play a significant part in extending our present summer season well into October. And of course, it would also help to boost passenger numbers at Aer Lingus and Shannon Airport.

“The success of this scheme could be achieved by undertaking a major promotion in supermarkets in the UK i.e Tesco, Lidl, Aldi and Sainsbury’s etc. What I am proposing is that a similar scheme be introduced in their UK chains,” he added.

The one stipulation for UK visitors planning to avail of these free flights would be that they would have to spend a minimum of four nights in Ireland.

“What I am proposing is that we start thinking outside of the box when it comes to tourism promotion and in this regard Fáilte Ireland, Tourism Ireland and Shannon Development should support this proposal and introduce a pilot scheme in conjunction with Aer Lingus,” continued Cllr Keating.

“It is time for change in the way we sell our country abroad and in the manner in which we disperse our marketing funds so that we maximise the benefits for our local tourism sector and revive passenger traffic at Shannon Airport,” he added.

MANAGEMENT at SkyCourt in Shannon say they are disappointed that one of its anchor tenants closed its doors “out of the blue” last week, after just six months in operation.

Discount store Buy Lo opened in March with the creation of seven jobs. After enjoying brisk trade in the initial weeks, business subsequently declined, which led to the decision to close last Tuesday.

The manager of SkyCourt, Pat Kelly, told The Clare People that the decision came “out of the blue” and said he was in “complete shock” at the announcement.

“We are very disappointed with it because we put a lot of effort into getting Buy Lo into Shannon,” he said. “I was extremely disappointed to hear of their decision. It has come as a great shock not just to myself but to all the traders in the centre.”

He said that despite difficult times in the retail sector, he is hopeful that the unit can be filled.

“We have been on to a number of operators. It is early days yet. We would be hopeful of getting somebody,” he said.

He said that the number of customers shopping at SkyCourt has fallen by about five per cent this year, but the spend is “down a good bit”.

“We are going to be doing our best to get another operator. It’s a fine store, fully kitted out. We did a lot of work in the unit before they moved in,” said Mr Kelly. The work includ- ed the provision of a new entrance and additional parking at the back.

“The fact that we have Dunnes and Lidl doing very similar to what Buy Lo were doing, maybe there was too much of a crossover,” said Mr Kelly.

“Ideally we are looking for something in the clothes line. We would love to get a replacement for it. We need to check the market and see who is looking to expand,” he added.

In a statement, BuyLo said it regretted that it had to make the decision to close.

BuyLo Store Manager, Sean Leo said the decision has been taken for commercial reasons. “We very much regret today’s decision which is a very difficult one for all of us working here at BuyLo in Shannon,” said Mr Leo, on Tuesday.

“The retail industry is being exposed to particularly challenging trading conditions at present and, unfortunately, our store has fallen victim to these difficulties. I would like to take this opportunity to pay special tribute to our seven staff members who have all worked extremely hard since the store opened earlier this year,” he added.

CLARE County Council has spent € 20 million on Traveller accommodation in Clare over the past 10 years, according to a new report.

The council has invested in 10 group housing schemes and one temporary site in the county that were put in place over three Traveller accommodation programmes since 2000. According to a report prepared by Bernadette Kinsella, Director of Housing, Social and Cultural Services, the capital cost between 2001 and 2011 has been € 20 million.

The report provides a detailed breakdown of all costs associated with Traveller accommodation incurred by the council.

It shows that maintenance costs of Traveller accommodation are “high relative to other accommodation provided by the council”.

Ms Kinsella explains that the council incurred high security costs on the Beechpark group scheme in Ennis, which was the subject of criminal damage and remains the subject of threat and intimidation since 2010.

The report adds, “Efforts to let three refurbished houses in this scheme are ongoing but unsuccessful due to intimidation and threats within the Traveller community. While the council has reported all such incidents to the Gardaí, victim statements have not been lodged with the Gardaí.”

The report states that a total of five units of accommodation have been destroyed by arson attack in the last 22 months (Beechpark, Ashline, Ballymaley). “Tenancy sustainment over time is an ongoing challenge and the turnover of accommodation units is a further driver of maintenance expenditure,” the report adds.

According to the report, “several hundred thousand euro have been incurred in defending these complaints, in addition to an inestimable staffing cost”.

Ms Kinsella states that in 2009 the council instituted judicial review proceedings to prohibit the Equality Tribunal from proceeding with hearings.

She continues, “Approximately 1,300 complaints were referred to the Tribunal by Ms Heather Rosen on behalf of Travellers. As each complaint carries a potential award of damages of € 6,000, the council is exposed to significant potential cost. To date 73 decisions have been issued by the Tribunal and all these cases were dismissed.”

In terms of staff resources the report shows that “five full-time and one part-time staff are deployed to work exclusively on Traveller accommodation issues, the majority of the focus being on resolving and responding to matters in respect of Travellers who have been accommodated by the council”.

It continues, “The council’s capacity to continue to commit this dis-proportionate level of resources, in the context of our overall housing stock of 1, 500 units and of ever diminishing staff resources is seriously limited.”

COURT FACILITIES in Clare have been “a total mess”, with the exception of Ennis and Kilrush, according to retiring Judge Joseph Mangan.

The Judge made the statement in his first interview since stepping down from the bench at Ennis District Court on Friday.

He told The Clare People that Killaloe court – which currently sits in Ennis – should be reopened and that courts should also return to Ennistymon (they currently sit in Kilrush). Over the years, while on the bench, the judge repeatedly hit out at conditions in various courtrooms across the county, due to the cold conditions and poor acoustics.

“One would have to say in Ennis facilities are perfectly satisfactory. One could say the same about Kilrush. Gort isn’t bad. After that, the facilities that we have had in this district were a total mess,” he said.

“When the District Court was set up at the foundation of the State, it was intended to be an accessible court. It’s the only court that most people see.

“When I first came to the district, I would have wanted to keep every venue open, but unfortunately the reality is there are no votes in courthouses. There are no votes to be got out of making courthouses an issue.

“When a court venue is closed, you will from time to time observe a local representative publicly shedding tears over the fact. Ask any one of them if they every put their head inside a court in the 30 years before the closure to observe the conditions in which work had been done. I believe that any society that allows justice to be administered in such appalling conditions has very little respect for itself as a nation,” he said.

“In retrospect, I think it was right to close a number of the outlying courts (in Clare) because of the conditions in which they had to function and the lack of realistic expectation of anything being done about them in the foreseeable future.

“I don’t believe it would be right to close any of the existing ones, including Killaloe and Athenry. Killaloe is temporarily closed and I know there is a wish on the part of the Courts Service to close it permanently. In fact, the expense caused to the guards by closing Killaloe would probably double the saving made by the courts service by closing it,” he said.

CONCERNS over burglaries and the theft of scrap metal and home heating oil will be on the agenda when the Joint Policing Committee meets in Shannon later this month.

One of the JPC meetings is held in public every year and the next Shannon meeting, on Monday, October 24 (Oakwood Arms Hotel), at 8pm, is open to the public.

Those with queries on crime prevention and general policing are invited to attend the meeting and submit any questions in advance of the event. It will give members of the public the chance to make their views known or ask questions of members of the committee which includes gardaí, local councillors and community representatives.

The chairman of the Shannon JPC, Councillor Tony McMahon, said that home security is an issue for homeowners in the town. However, he said that overall, residents are generally happy with the crime levels in the town.

“In Shannon, we don’t have a whole lot of issues. Security has been a concern. There have been a number of break-ins. There are concerns in some areas. Heating oil and scrap metal seem to be the focus of a lot of attention. People need to be alert and aware of that. Overall, though, policing is working quite well in Shannon.

“There is always a concern about drugs but when we look at the figures presented at each meeting the gardaí seem to be in control,” said Mr McMahon.

“Public order is not a huge factor,” he added.

He said that a number of local disputes, which have led to concern in some parts of the town “wouldn’t reflect on the overall situation in the town”.

“In general, the crime levels are as good as can be expected in a town of its population,” he said.

“We would like to see more gardaí on the beat but there are a number of gardaí on bikes which is good,” he added.

A number of local schools including community alert, neighbourhood watch and business watch schemes have been set up in Shannon and surrounding areas over the past few years. These have been credited with preventing some crime in the area.

“They seem to be working very well. The two community gardaí there are to be commended,” said Mr McMahon.

He is urging people to attend the public meeting. “It is essential that people attend public meetings. It’s a forum giving people the opportunity to express their concerns,” he said.

Those interested in submitting queries should do so to the Shannon Town Clerk Liam O’Connor: email shannontclerk@eircom.net or phone 061 362319 by 5pm on Friday.

A SMALL number of Traveller families are causing a lot of concern and costing Clare County Council a lot of money, a meeting has heard.

Those were the comments made by County Manager Tom Coughlan at yesterday’s meeting of Clare County Council. Mr Coughlan was speaking after a new report revealed the high cost incurred by the council in providing Traveller accommodation over the past 10 years.

Mr Coughlan told the meeting that a small percentage of families in Clare were behind many of the problems associated with accommodation including, vandalism and intimidation of council staff. Mr Coughlan said Clare County Council had led the field when it came to providing Traveller accommodation.

He said that the last specific piece of Traveller legislation had been introduced 23 years ago. He suggested that it was now time to examine legislation in the area of Traveller accommodation, saying further discussion and debate on the matter would be helpful to local authorities.

Commenting on figures that show that 1,300 complaints have been referred to the Equality Tribunal, Mr Coughlan said that if all cases are heard individually “it will take up a lot of council time and resources”.

Mr Coughlan paid tribute to staff working in the council’s housing section, saying that the job can be “extremely difficult and demoralising”. “There is a limit to the amount of money and staff the council can put into this,” he added. At the meeting, councillors expressed concern at the rising costs of the programme. Cllr Tommy Brennan (Ind) pro- posed that the council stop spending money on Traveller accommodation until such time as new legislation is introduced. “It’s high time they were taught a lesson,” he added. Cllr Joe Arkins (FG) said that while Travellers have rights and entitlements, they also have duties and responsibilities. “But it seems to me that with elements of the Traveller community, it’s all a one way street.” Commenting on the council’s report, which shows that the percentage of rent collected for Traveller accommodation is low, Cllr Arkins said rent should be deducted at source from Social Welfare payments. “There are only so many times you can get two fingers in the face,” he added. Cllr Patricia McCarthy (Ind) said that the figures contained in the report were very “disheartening” given the council’s ongoing commitment to providing Traveller accommodation. Cllr James Breen (Ind) said the gardaí should be invited to speak on incidents of vandalism and arson at Traveller accommodation at the next council meeting.