The Clare People Archive

A JUDGE has asked the gardaí to investigate the circumstances in which a second teenager from Ennis was married by a man claiming to be a ‘Bishop’.

At Ennis Children’s Court on Wednesday, Judge Patrick Durcan said, “It is disgraceful that this young man is being duped by someone who parades around pretending to be a Bishop”.

He was speaking after being told by a 17 year old boy he had recently been married by Bishop Michael Cox.

The youth – who cannot be named for legal reasons and was before the court on a trespass charge – confirmed to Judge Durcan that he paid € 100 to Mr Cox for the marriage and that he met him only once before the wedding.

He told the judge that he and his wife are expecting their first child in August. The legal age for marriage in Ireland is 18.

Judge Durcan said he wanted the issue to be brought to the attention of the State.

Addressing the teenager, Judge Durcan said, “This man is not a Bishop and he is not entitled to marry you.”

He told the boy this could have seri- ous implications for the status of his marriage, the status of his wife and the status of his child his wife is expecting.

Judge Durcan noted this was the second time in recent months he had been informed of a marriage performed by Bishop Cox for an Ennis teenager.

Last November he ordered gardaí to investigate the circumstances of a wedding of another 17 year-old performed by Bishop Cox.

At the time, Judge Durcan was strongly critical of Bishop Cox. He said the fact that the couple had paid money for the service was “appalling” and “brings things to the lowest depths.”

“I want to say loudly and clearly that anyone who masquerades as a clergy man and who takes money from young people and imbues in them a mistaken belief that he has married them, is in my view committing the most serious offence”, added Judge Durcan.

On Wednesday, Inspector Tom Kennedy told the court the case is under investigation.

Judge Durcan said he also wanted the Probation Services to investigate how young people are being “duped” into paying for sham marriage ceremonies.

Probation Officer, Eoin Ryan said the case has been discussed by the service.

Bishop Cox previously attracted controversy when he ordained Sinead O’Connor a priest in 1999 in Lourdes — he is not a bishop of the Roman Catholic Church and is instead a bishop of the Latin Tridentine Church.

A KILRUSH man found guilty of illegally dumping household waste will have to pay out € 1,030, following a hearing at Kilrush District Court on Tuesday.

Clare County Council brought the case against Flan Burke, Apartment 2, Vandeleur Street, Kilrush who was found guilty of littering contrary to section 3(1) of Litter Pollution Act 1997 and Section 24 (1) of the Lit- ter Pollution Act 1997 as Amended Section 58. In evidence litter warden Conor Leyden said that the council received a complaint on July 2, 2013 stating that there was litter on the side of the road at Dunneill, Kilimer.

On investigating the complaint he found an ESB bill with Mr Burke’s name among the rubbish.

A fine was sent to Mr Burke by registered post.

He was also told he could appeal the fine in writing, the court was told, but this did not happen.

Reminder letters were again sent on July 29 and August 6, 2013 and finally a court summons was issued on December 31.

Mr Leyden described the road as a “quiet road with no residential houses, with mostly agricultural lands.”

Describing Mr Burke’s actions as “contemptible” Judge Patrick Durcan fined him € 750 and ordered him to pay costs of € 280.

He added that he was taking into account that the defendant in the case had no previous convictions.

THREE men found guilty of damaging a car during a religious ceremony at a graveyard outside Ennis have been given eight months to pay full compensation to their victim.

Michael Doherty (52), Patrick Doherty (34) and James Galbraith (45) were convicted in November (2013) of criminal damage.

They were ordered by Judge William Early to pay € 7000 compensation to the victim. Judge Early said if the money was paid, he would recommend a six month suspended sentence for each accused.

The case came back before Ennis District Court on Tuesday where solicitor for the Dohertys, Daragh Hassett, said his clients did not have the full amount of compensation.

Mr Hassett told Judge Early his clients had € 500.

He said Michael and Patrick Doherty are both on social welfare and required time to get the outstanding compensation.

Defence solicitor for Mr Galbraith, John Casey said his client also had € 500 for the court and required further time.

He said Mr Galbraith has moved away from Ennis and had to spend money on securing new accommodation.

“The move from Ennis, to get away from this trouble, has cost him”, explained Mr Casey.

Judge William Early agreed to adjourn the case to October to allow the men time bring the remaining € 6,000 to court.

Judge Early warned the accused he would impose the default sentence of six months in prison if the money was not paid by October.

Inspector Michael Gallagher told the court the men had not come to garda attention since November.

Michael Doherty and Patrick Doherty, both with addresses at St Michael’s Park, Ballymaley, Ennis and James Galbraith, formerly of Lissaniska, Ennis and now living in Bettystown, Meath, all denied the charge of criminal damage at Drumcliff graveyard on March 24, 2013.

In November Ennis District Court heard mother of two Kathleen Maughan was visiting her husband’s grave when her Ford Focus car was damaged in a violent attack.

Ms Maughan told the court she saw three men armed with slash hooks and hatchets alight from vehicles and attack her car on March 24, 2013.

Ms Maughan, who is from Ennis but now lives in Cork, was one of a group of 20 people attending a blessing of the graves ceremony.

After hearing the evidence, Judge William Early said, “I believe the evidence of Ms Maughan.

“I believe she is telling the truth, therefore it must follow that I find them guilty as charged.”

Judge Early said it seemed to be the case that Ms Maughan was a “victim of one of these wretched family feuds that are all too common in the Traveller community”.

There was a heated conclusion to the hearing of the case in November. A flurry of insults were fired at Ms Maughan from people sitting in the gallery A MA N accused of using a knife during alleged robberies at two businesses in Ennis last year is to be sent forward for trial to the Circuit Court. James Hayes (26) with an address at Dun Na hInse, Ennis appeared at Ennis District Court on Wednesday. Mr Hayes is charged with the robbery of a woman at Glamorize, O’Connell, Street on November 25, 2013. It is alleged Mr Hayes took €400. He is also charged with production of a knife during the course of the alleged offence. It is further alleged Mr Hayes did rob €70 froma woman at Vaughan’s Florist, Ennis on December 12, 2013. He is also charged with the production of a knife arising fromthe same alleged robbery offence. Inspector TomKennedy told the court the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has directed the cases proceed to trial on indictment, meaning they will be heard in the Circuit Court. Defence solicitor Tara Godfrey told the court her client suffers frommuscular dystrophy and his movement has become more restricted. She said the High Court had previously directed prison authorities to provide appropriate care for Mr Hayes. He was remanded in custody to appear again at Ennis District Court on February 19 for service of the book of evidence. A W OMA N has appeared in court charged with child neglect at a Clare address. The 22-year-old woman appeared before Ennis District Court onWednesday. It is alleged the woman had in her care a child whomshe allegedly ill-treated, neglected, abandoned or exposed the child, or caused the child to be assaulted, ill-treated, neglected, abandoned or exposed, in a manner likely to cause unnecessary suffering or injury to the child’s health or seriously to affect his or her wellbeing. The charge relates to an alleged incident at a mid-Clare address in October 2012.The alleged offence is contrary to the Children’s Act Inspector TomKennedy said he believed this was the first charge of its type he had seen come before the court where the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) had directed summary disposal. Insp Kennedy said he suspected the case may be an indictable matter and would probably have to be referred back to the DPP. He said the issue of jurisdiction would also have to be addressed. The accused was remanded on continuing bail to appear again at Ennis District Court on February 26. A JUDGE has refused jurisdiction of a case where it is alleged a man was found in possession of a slash hook near the grounds of Ennis Courthouse. Michael Keenan (23), with an address at Meelagh View, Mahon, Cork, is alleged to have had a slash hook which had a blade or which was sharply pointed at Steele’s Terrace, Ennis on November 28, 2013. The alleged offence is contrary to the firearms and offensive weapons act. The case came before Ennis District Court on Wednesday to allowJudge Patrick Durcan consider jurisdiction. Garda Francis Brennan of Ennis Garda Station told the court the slash hook was allegedly found in the back of Mr Keenan’s vehicle. Garda Brennan said it would be alleged Mr Keenan denied any knowledge of having the alleged weapon. After seeing the slash hook, Judge Durcan refused jurisdiction, meaning the case will nowproceed to the Circuit Court. Defence solicitor Tara Godfrey consented to an extension of time for service of the book of evidence.The case was adjourned to April 9. A FIFT EEN year-old boy has appeared in court charged in connection with an alleged violent disturbance in the Market area of Ennis last year. The boy, accompanied by his mother, appeared before Ennis Children’s Court onWednesday. Inspector TomKennedy told the court the case is connected to that of two other accused who will be sent forward for trial to the Circuit Court. He said that as this charge concerns a juvenile, the presiding district court Judge must decide the issue of jurisdiction and not the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The teenager is charged with unlawful possession of a weapon. Insp Kennedy said the charge relates to an alleged incident at Lower Market Street, Ennis on February 18, 2013. Insp Kennedy said it would be alleged the alleged injured party’s car was attacked. He said the incident allegedly involved three people carrying weapons including hatchets and a machete. He said the alleged incident took place around 7.30pm. Judge Patrick Durcan refused jurisdiction. Insp Kennedy said a book of evidence would have to be prepared in the case. The teenager was remanded on continuing bail.

AN ENGLISH conman who duped businesses on a € 1,300 “nationwide tour” of hotels in Ireland has received a 12-month prison sentence.

David Brown (57) was arrested by gardaí in Clare last week after failing to pay for food and alcohol at the Ravine Hotel, Lisdoonvarna, on February 11.

It came after gardaí issued a nationwide alert for Mr Brown’s arrest after he committed a string of similar offences at hotels around the country between January 25 and February 12.

He appeared before Ennis District Court on Thursday.

Mr Brown, with an address at Mallard Road, Scunthorpe, England, pleaded guilty to six changes of dishonestly by deception availing of food, accommodation and beverages.

The charges relate to Mr Brown’s stay at Creevy Pier Hotel, Ballyshan- non, Donegal, where he accrued a bill of € 333 between February 4 and 6; his stay at Lismore House, Lismore, Waterford, between January 25 and 27 where the bill came to € 382 and the Templemore Arms Hotel, Templemore, between February 1 and 3 where the bill came to € 271.

He also admitted offences at Dunning’s, The Octagon, Westport, between February 7 and 8 (€ 65) and Murphy’s Law, Barrack Street, Athlone, between February 3 and 4 (€ 150).

Judge Patrick Durcan enquired what type of food and drink Mr Brown availed of during his stays at the hotels. Inspector Tom Kennedy replied that the accused was “pretty accomplished at entertaining himself”.

Garda Shane Kavanagh of Ennistymon Garda Station said he arrested Mr Brown in the early hours of February 12 after the accused failed to pay for drink and food worth € 81 at the Ravine Hotel, Lisdoonvarna.

Garda Kavanagh told the court Mr Brown would typically tell hoteliers he was over from England to do maintenance work on telegraph poles. He would claim his colleagues were arriving in a few days and they would pay the bill. “He would book in on a Friday but by Monday morning he’d be gone,” added Garda Kavanagh.

The court heard Mr Brown travelled across the country by hitch hiking and getting lifts from fellow ‘guests’.

Insp Kennedy said Mr Brown has 50 previous convictions, many for deception offences, and was only released from prison in January.

Defence solicitor Tara Godfrey said her client is divorced and previously worked as an unskilled labourer.

She said Mr Brown was homeless when he was released from prison and committed the offences as a means of surviving.

She said her client had mainly drank pints of lager and eaten burg- ers and pies during his time at the hotels. “The most extravagant thing he had was a Jack Daniels whiskey,” she added.

She asked the court to consider deporting Mr Brown back to the United Kingdom.

Judge Patrick Durcan said this was an “unusual case” one where like his countrymen did in the past, Mr Brown commenced his journey through Ireland in Waterford.

He said Mr Brown had perpetrated a “reign of commercial tyranny” against tourism businesses, many of whom are based in coastal communities devastated by recent storms.

“His spree, his nationwide tour, cost € 1,322,” added Judge Durcan.

“The only order I can make is one that forces the Irish people to pay € 1,700 a week to accommodate him further,” he said.

He imposed sentences totalling 12 months but suspended the final eight months on condition Mr Brown enter a bond to be of good behaviour. TWOmen have appeared in court charged in connection with an alleged burglary in the Corrovorrin area of Ennis. Patrick Ballard (28) and Michael Clune (28) are alleged to have entered 2 Corrovorrin,Tulla Road, Ennis as trespassers and attempted to commit theft therein.The charge relates to an alleged break in on December 11, 2013. Mr Ballard, with an address at Lifford Lodge, Lifford Road, Ennis and Mr Clune with an address at BridgeviewCourt, Ennis, both appeared before Ennis District Court onWednesday. The court heard the DPP has directed summary disposal of the cases in the district court. Legal aid was approved for solicitor Tara Godfrey. Ms Godfrey said she required time to seek disclosure fromthe State. The cases were adjourned to April 2 for the accused to enter pleas or to fix a date for hearing. A POLISH man who admits being in an intoxicated state at Ennis Cathedral will carry our volountary work in the town, a court has heard. Last November, Judge Patrick Durcan said he wanted Tomasz Hajduk (43) to get involved with a group like Ennis Tidy Towns to make up for his behaviour in the upper O’Connell Street area of the town on November 13. Tomasz Hajduk, with addresses at Sandfield Apartments, Sandfield Road, Ennis and Cree, pleaded guilty to being intoxicated to such an extent so as to be a danger to himself and to others. Gardaí found Mr Hajduk in an intoxicated state outside Ennis Cathedral and he has a number of previous convictions mainly for public order offences, the court heard. The case came back before Ennis District Court on Wednesday where solicitor William Cahir told the court his client had secured work with Ennis Parish on a voloutary basis. Judge Patrick Durcan adjourned the case to October 1 for review. Addressing Mr Hajduk, he said, “I expect you will so some work for the church”.

AN ENNIS woman has received an 18-month prison sentence for a string of offences including stealing money from a pensioner and assaulting a garda.

Ann Marie Molloy stole € 200 from 85-year-old Anne McCullagh as the pensioner walked through Paddy Quinn’s car park in Ennis on November 1, 2013.

At Ennis District Court on Wednesday, Detective Garda Claire O’Shaughnessy said Ms Molloy grabbed Ms McCullagh’s handbag before running away.

“She was extremely upset and crying. She was tramautised by the whole experience,” said Detective O’Shaughnessy of Ms McCullagh’s condition after the theft.

Ann Marie Molloy, with an address at Ballaghboy Halting Site, Quin Road Ennis, pleaded guilty to punching and kicking a female garda at Ennis Garda Station on May 14, 2012. She also pleaded guilty to a number of other theft and trespass offences including a break in at the Maria Assumpta Hall, Station Road, Ennis, between August 29 and 31, 2012, and theft of a wallet from a woman in a cinema on February 12, 2013.

She also admitted damaging post boxes at the Mill Road apartment complex. The court heard it cost the owner € 595 to repair to damage.

Defence solicitor Tara Godfrey said her client came from a large family of 13. She said Ms Molloy has learning difficulties and a drinking problem. “She’s a lovely lady with a horrible problem with drink,” she added.

Ms Godfrey urged the court not to impose custodial sentence but rather remand her client in custody for a period to “frighten her into understanding what she did”.

An offer to pay compensation to Ms McCullagh was rejected by Judge Patrick Durcan. He said he was not impressed by people who bring money to court trying to buy their way out of jail. He said he would much rather hear compensation had already been paid.

He said Ms Molloy engaged in “horrendous criminal activity” over a 12-month period. He said he was cognizant of her family background, physical and intellectual difficulties and problems with alcohol.

In the case of the theft from Ms McCullagh, Judge Durcan said the victim had “gallantly and valiantly fought back but had been left in a distressed state”. He imposed sentences totalling 18 months. Judge Durcan warned assaults against gardaí and the robbery of old women would be met with the toughest measures open to the court. Recognizance were set in the event of an appeal.

AN ENVIRONMENTALIST has maintained that a windfarm, which is currently part of a planning application to Clare County Council, will be visible from Doonbeg Golf Course.

Friends of the Irish Environment director Tony Lowes, who in 2000 held up the construction of the course when he raised concerns in the high court about the protection of the microscopic snail Vertigo Angustior, told a Scottish newspaper that he now wants new owner Donald Trump to help back a campaign against the proposed nine-turbine wind farm.

The billionaire businessman reportedly ceased plans to build a second luxury golf course in Aberdeenshire, Scotland, following a failed legal battle to stop the construction of an 11-turbine windfarm off the Scottish coast.

Last week West Clare Coastal Windpower lodged plans for the nine 126-metre wind turbines at Carrowmore South, Einagh and Shragh, two kilometres south of Doonbeg village.

The company’s previous plan for an “industrial scale” € 200 million windfarm at the same location was refused by an Bord Pleanála last July.

Local business people said this week that they were taking a “neutral stance” on the issue, and that the previous application went through the process without any major concern locally.

Mr Lowes is reported as saying he believes people will listen to Mr Trump rather than the environmentalists on the issue.

Asked about the Trump Organisation getting involved in any such issues locally, executive vice president Eric Trump said it was not afraid of taking on important issues.

“Maybe it is too early, but we have never been afraid to tackle important issues time and time again, and we have never been afraid to take on important issues,” she told The Clare People .

“We are not afraid to take on the fight for the betterment of the community and quite frankly often times the community looks to us to lean on, to help them and for that leadership and for the resources to do so.”

DOONBEG was this week welcoming the investment by the Trump Organisation in the local Greg Norman designed golf course and hotel, and said it is looking forward to working with the new owners.

The community in Doonbeg have experience when it comes to deal- ing with large international companies and local development, having initiated the development of the world-renowned golf course in the late 1990s and manoeuvred its way through many issues surrounding its later development and expansion.

Rare snails, rights of ways and access to the beach were all difficult and emotive issues that have been worked through in the community and in the courts, but that hard work is now done, according to Doonbeg Community Development Ltd.

The chairman of the community group Willie Hanrahan said the investment by the Trump family “secures the whole golf course; it secures the properties, it secures the jobs and the on going facilities in the area”.

He said the financial backing of the company will have a major impact on the area. “If they help with the coastal erosion and secure the property that would be fantastic.”

He has no concerns that relationships may sour down the line, as Doonbeg is an established golf course and facility.

“There are always problems when you set up something new. Doonbeg is there. It is established. We have been there and done that. We had problems with the rights of way. We had problems with the access to the beach. They have all been sorted. They are all secured now. There will always be ongoing issues but we have a very good relationship with the management, with Joe Russell at the moment and the current management and we would hope that will continue,” he said.

IN THE 24 hours after news broke that Doonbeg golf club and hotel was to become Trump International Golf Links Ireland, traffic to the Doonbeg website multiplied five times.

Eric Trump said the Trump name brought with it new recognition from people who may not even have heard of the west of Ireland, never mind Doonbeg, and testimony to the interest in the newly-acquired resort and golf course was evident from the online searches.

According to Doonbeg Managing Director Joe Russell the week had been full of bombshells.

“The initial atmosphere was one of surprise that somebody of Donald Trump’s stature, and international recognition decided to take on Doonbeg,” he said

The property and business was just four weeks in receivership when the deal was done.

“When it came on the market I found out it created a certain ripple around the market of ‘my goodness Doonbeg is up for sale, let’s go for it’,” explained Mr Russell.

Donald Trump Jnr, Executive Vice President of the Trump Organisation, had toured the golf courses of Ireland two years ago, and Doonbeg had left a lasting impression.

“It’s the location. It’s the quality of the property. It’s what we have done since we opened, in terms of awards, recognition, hospitality. We have our own selves and our own success to thank to get someone like Donald Trump here,” said Mr Russell.

“On a larger scale it is a huge vote of confidence for Ireland, West Clare, Clare. We got Donald Trump!”

“They are a big company, they have the resources, they have the engine in terms of marketing, there is a structure there as it relates to how one does things.

“It will probably move us out of our current comfort zone in terms of how we do things, but that is to be expected when you join an organisa- tion, when you change an organisation. If you went into a new job you would have to modify your practises and your approach as to how you do things. But they didn’t come here for no reason. They came here to take what’s here and take it to the next level in terms of the amenity development, and they are bringing a lot to the party too in terms of expertise,” said the managing director.

He is not surprised however that Doonbeg is an attractive location.

“It is a very special destination and at least now we have a very good chance. The day you stand still in this business you are dead in the water,” he added, happy that there is potential to develop the tourism business further.

“Everywhere this organisation goes it appears to have an affect. There is an immediate impact. There is an operational impact. For me they expand our facilities again, I don’t have definitive on what they are talking about doing but there will be things put in to grow the business.”

When the golf course opened more than a decade ago, it brought with it the job equivalent of a major international company to a city.

“Something of this magnitude moving into a rural location in Ireland at the time was significant, it was major press, similarly you have a situation where you have Trump Organisation now coming into Doonbeg,” said Mr Russell.

But how will Trump tally with the area.

“How will it fit? Certainly the local community will see itself as responsible for a business being here at all. Many of them have worked with the club from a community perspective,” said Mr Russell adding that community involvement must be retained and built upon.

“It is not the castle on the hill. It is part of the community. If you ever move away from that ethos and you ever become anything other than that I think you are in trouble. 40 per cent of our market is North America, what most of those people want to do is go to the village, they want to drive around and if there is any hostility towards the club that will seek it out.”

“This is a destination now. You look around – Loop Head right up to Kilkee, to Doonbeg right up to the Cliffs of Moher, this is a destination.”

A WEST Clare developer who raped a Brazilian woman he had asked to clean his house has been sentenced to seven and a half years, after a judge said he couldn’t “buy himself out” of a custodial sentence.

He had denied the charge. Mr Justice White said that on reading the victim impact report provided by the victim, he did not believe the rape had “a profound psychological effect” on her. “It strikes me that your victim is more interested in compensation rather than anything else,” he said.

“WE PLAN to spend a lot of money, obviously fix the course, make it play perfect and integrate it with a hotel collection.”

Eric Trump literally blew into West Clare on Storm Darwin on Wednesday night with his older brother and fellow Executive Vice President Donald Jnr just one day after they reputedly paid € 15 million for the 18hole golf links, hotel and spa.

Even though the five star lodge was dimly lit amid a local power outage, the businessmen were impressed with the authenticity of the architec- ture and the rugged beauty of the surrounding area. The American brothers, sons of the world famous Donald Trump, announced that the existing jobs would be safe at the resort and even more will come on stream in the next six months to a year they promised, and it was all good news.

“You are putting a property in a very, very big engine and I think that is a very good thing for the region. I think it will bring a tremendous amount of people here,” Eric Trump told The Clare People. The Lodge at Doonbeg, now known as Trump International Golf Links Ireland, is West Clare’s largest employer.