Author: admin

A JURY has returned verdicts of accidental death at the inquests of two men who drowned off the West Clare coast last year.

64-year-old Skipper Michael Galvin and his 35-year-old neighbour Noel Dickinson drowned when their boat, the Lady Eileen, sank off the coast of Quilty last August. Their disappearance sparked a massive search that at one stage involved around 20 boats various search and rescue services.

Inquests into the men’s deaths were held at Clare County Coroner’s Court on Wednesday. They heard that Liz Galvin was the last person to see her husband and Mr Dickinson alive be- fore they left for sea.

In her draft deposition read in court, Ms Galvin stated it was not unusual for the men to spend a long day working at sea.

Martin Kiely of Aughinish Diving Club and James McMahon of Burren Sub Aqua Club told the inquest they found the bodies of the men in the wheelhouse of the Lady Eileen.

The inquest heard that the men had been part of a dive team searching the water off Breaffa South. The bodies of the men, who both lived at Seaview Park, were taken ashore at Seafield Pier, Quilty, on August 14. Death was pronounced by Dr Billy O’Connell.

Both men were fishermen but the inquest heard that Mr Dickinson also worked as a chef. Autopsies were performed at the Mid Western Regional Hospital, Limerick.

Dr Elizabeth Mulcahy told the inquest that blood analysis revealed a negative or zero reading for ethanol in both men.

Dr Mulcahy said that in her opinion, death was due to drowning.

County Coroner Isobel O’Dea suggested to the jury that the appropriate verdict to return was one of either accidental death or death by misadventure.

After declining an offer to retire to consider their decision, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of accidental death with drowning as the cause of death. Ms O’Dea extended her sympathy to both families on the tragic losses of Michael Galvin and Noel Dickinson. She also paid tribute to the rescue services who assisted in the search.

Ms O’Dea noted the findings of the official Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB) report, which found that the Lady Eileen probably encountered wind or wave action on the day it sank. Ms O’Dea noted the weather had been particularly bad at the time.

She said she was conscious that the first anniversary of the men’s death would be marked this week.

Inspector Michael Gallagher expressed sympathy on behalf of the gardaí.

Family members were present in court for the inquests.

AN EAST Clare manufacturing company has begun lobbying the Government to provide grant assistance for water conservation in domestic homes next year when the home insulation grants finish.

RainSavers, a Tuamgraney company that builds and installs the world’s only rain water recovery units that pumps water of drinking quality back into the home, believes that the system will not only save householders on their water charges but will also take pressure off local authority water supplies.

Denis Sheehy, Director of RainSavers, said, with the onset of domestic water charges next year, he feels now is the time for Government to make such a commitment.

“It actually benefits county councils massively because at the moment the councils’ municipal water supplies are over stretched. What has happened is housing has increased drastically but the infrastructure to provide water to houses hasn’t.

“We believe that if the county council would consider grant aiding rainwater recovery within urban areas then there would be an enormous reduction on the municipal supply systems, thus allowing the present infrastructure to return within optimum operating capacity and reducing the cost on local authorities,” he said.

He said the system, which retails at approximately € 4, 500 would also benefit the householder and pay for itself in four years. “Of a standard 2,000 square foot house with four people occupancy, one of our systems would supply enough water for that house for the year. What the house would only be using is the standard charge and their free water usage, they should not be going above that at all in a year,” he said.

A SEARCH is expected to resume today for a man missing from his home in Ennis since Saturday. Seamus Higgins (22) was last seen jumping a wall after leaving his house at Dun Na hInse on the Lahinch Road at around 3pm on Sat- urday. He was wearing jeans, new navy and white, laceless, Nike runners and a grey jumper. Members of Clare Civil Defence have carried out searches of the nearby Claureen river and riverbank area. Extensive searches have also taken place in Lees Road and in vacant houses and abandoned buildings in the town. That search is expected to be expanded around Ennis today (Tuesday). Gardaí in Ennis were notified within five hours of Mr Higgins’ disappearance on Saturday. They have asked for the public’s assistance in finding Mr Higgins. An appeal for information has also been issued through social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter. Gardaí have expressed concern for Mr Higgins. He left the house without his phone, wallet and passport. Mr Higgins’ foster mother, Tina Whelan, said she is concerned for Seamus’ well being. She said, “He just got up and left the house without saying a word which isn’t like Seamus. He would always say where he is going. One of the neighbours saw him hopping over a wall. His friends are very upset. I am upset. We just hope that he turns up.” Anyone who may have seen Seamus Higgins or who may have information as to his whereabouts is asked to contact Ennis Garda Station on 065 6848100.

THE famous Kilfenora Céilí Band will lead an audacious attempt to bring a new Guinness World Record back to Clare later this month.

The band will lead an attempt on Sunday, August 25, to set the world record for the largest Irish band ever to play a tune. Amateur and professional musicians are invited to make the trip to Kilfenora on the day and help the Clare village set a new world record. Officials from the Guinness Book of Records will be in Kilfenora for the event and 250 musicians will be needed to set the world first.

“We want to get as many musicians as we possibly can in Kilfenora for the day and if we can get 250 or more to play then we will have set a world record,” said one of the organisers, Gerard Linnane.

“The attempt will be led by the Kilfenora Céilí Band who will come on stage at 3.30pm. We will have rows of chairs set up for the musicians in the square and the hope is that enough musicians will turn up on the day to help make it a reality.

“Anyone who is aged 12 years or older can take part and all that the need to know is how to play the famous Kilfenora Jig. There will be music in the village all afternoon and we will get a rehearsal in with everyone who is taking part before the main vent.”

Anyone who wants to take part can register in Kilfenora on the day be tween 12 noon and 2.30pm. Volunteers will also be collecting money for Kilfenora Senior Citizens and The Irish Cancer Society at the event.

More information is available from www.largestirishband.ie or by ringing Gerard Linnane on 065 7088157.

THE Bishop of Inis Cathaigh (Scattery Island) and Auxiliary Bishop of Brooklyn in New York Most Reverend Frank J. Caggiano has apologised to the people of Kilrush for pulling out of plans to celebrate Mass on the monastic island at the 11th hour.

The bishop was forced to change his plans to celebrate the Mass last weekend due to financial constraints, both in his own budget and the budget of the local authority in Clare.

The bishop, who holds the ancient title of Bishop of Scattery Island since his ordination in August 2006, accepted an invitation from Kilrush Town Council and the local committee Comóradh Sheanáin Naofa to celebrate the annual Mass on the year of the Gathering.

In July his secretary wrote to Kilrush Town Council asking if the bishop would be reimbursed for his travel expenses.

The council members agreed that they did not have the funds to cover the costs, and did not usually cover any costs of visiting dignitaries to the town.

The bishop then contacted the town clerk John Corry just weeks before the Mass expressing his regret that he could not visit Kilrush due to budgetary issues.

“In the reply that I received from Most Rev Caggianos office regarding his visit to Ireland it appears that the cost of the trip to Kilrush appeared to be the problem,” Mr Corry told The Clare People .

“His offices indicated that because of the limited travel funds in their budget, they determined that it was not feasible for the Bishop to travel to Ireland for the Mass. They estimated the cost of this trip at $1,800 and with the bishop previously scheduled to participate in the Youth 2000 Summer Festival in mid-August, an additional cost like this would off-set their expenses.

“They expressed their sincerest apologies for the short notice and change in plans,” said Mr Corry.

Chairperson of Comóradh Sheanáin Naofa Cllr Tom Prendeville (FF), who first proposed the invitation to the council, said the group were disappointed that the bishop could not attend the special Mass.

Had he been able to make the trip he would have been the first Bishop of Scattery in living memory to visit the sixth century settlement.

“I understand why the county could not afford the bill, especially at such times of constraint. Maybe he might be able to come in the future.”

Cllr Prendeville said that other than the disappointment of not having Bishop Caggiano in attendance, the Mass and weekend of visits to the island was a huge success.

A DISTRESSED mother has told how she relied on the kindness of strangers who were themselves at the mercy of the health services, as she waited more than three hours to have her two-year-old daughter’s head injury assessed.

The long wait at the University Hospital Limerick’s Emergency Department (ED) began at 6.45pm on Tuesday.

The little girl had received a bang to the head earlier that evening after a gate swung back on her. The family travelled to the only hospital in the region permitted to take injured children under the age of five to have the head injury examined and treated.

After a long wait to see a nurse, the worried mother was less than satisfied when she was “asked how it happened, my name, my contact number and advised there were two people ahead of us and it would be approximately an hour before she would be seen”.

The little toddler was then sent back out to the waiting room with her wound open and uncovered.

“At 9.30pm, 2.45 hours later, I approached the reception desk at AandE and pleaded with the lady that she be reviewed as she was a child with a head injury. There were tears in my eyes by now,” said the upset mother.

“The lady behind the desk seemed surprised that she wasn’t reviewed and said she is a child who should be given priority,” she said, adding that she told her to go through to a room inside in the emergency department.

“I met a nurse there and I advised her that the lady in reception suggested I bring her in …. There was only one other patient in there at the time but the nurse advised I would have to leave and wait outside.”

Eventually more than three hours later she was called through to ED.

“During this time I stood with my child in my arms and tried to console her as much as I could. An elderly man on a stretcher bed actually got up and let her lie down on his bed for a few minutes so she could try and get comfortable. After a few minutes I felt bad for the man and moved her. Another woman gave me a chair.”

“When she was eventually called by the doctor at approximately 10pm she was extremely upset as she was tired, exhausted and sore. She got upset on entering the [examination] room and I tried to calm her down, she ran out and I followed her, as she was scared of what was going on. As I left the doctor shouted after me ‘you answer my questions and the nurse will go after her’. I kept walking after my daughter but I could hear a nurse saying to him the child needs her mother.

“I eventually calmed her down, with the help of a lovely woman who gave her some chocolate from her hand bag. The doctor approached us and asked if she was okay now and I advised yes – she understands what will happen, to which he replied, good I will see another patient and I will be back. I could not believe this, neither could patients or people in the area that witnessed it. My daughter is two and a half years old, had been waiting in a strange place for over three hours for a doctor and she got scared. She is only a child. I find it absolutely unacceptable that my daughter had to wait over three hours for a doctor to assess her head injury,” said her tired mother.

She paid tribute to the other patients who helped her through the ordeal stating “They were people who cared more about me than the nurses and doctors.”

Since the episode in the ED the little girl was taken to her GP at the weekend, as the cut was badly infected. She is now on antibiotics for the infection.

A UNIQUE horse and pony charity ride will begin in Clare on August 31 in a bid to raise much-needed funds for the Mid West Cancer Foundation.

Established in 2007, the centre is located on the grounds of the University Hospital Limerick and its main aim is to provide holistic care for people from Clare, Limerick and Tipperary with cancer through a wide range of services.

The foundation also supports research being carried out by the Stokes Institute.

All funds raised from the Ennis to Limerick charity ride will enhance the cancer centre’s facilities and will ensure that the best treatment, services and cutting edge technology is available to people with cancer in the mid-west area.

Co-director and credit controller of the event Ennis woman Paula Williams explained, “As parents we got thinking wouldn’t it be a lovely to do something in the mid-west for the people of the mid-west that involves both children and parents.”

The charity ride and drive will not just be going from Ennis to Limerick, but a second group of horses, ponies and riders will also make their way from Adare in Limerick to meet with the Clare group at the Limerick Greyhound Course.

On the day of the event route one leaves from the Showgrounds in Ennis with participants free to do a much or little of the ride as they wish. There will be stops along the way in Quin, Sixmilebridge and the Radison in Meelick for refreshments.

A raffle will be held at the end of the ride and six winners will be picked to lead out the grey hounds running in the 8.30 Mid-western Cancer Foundation Charity Race at the greyhound race.

“All the proceeds from the charity ride and drive, raised by sponsorship cards and collection buckets on the day will go to the Mid-Western Cancer foundation which was which is based at the University of Limerick,” said Ms Williams.

RATE payers in Ennis are facing an uncertain year in 2014 with the prospect of a split rate – with businesses paying more for the second half of the year than they do in the first six months.

The upcoming merger of Ennis Town Council and Clare County Council means that the Ennis authority will strike a rate for the first six months of the year in December and businesses in Ennis may be forced to pay a different “county” rate for the second hand of the year.

The difference between the rate charged by Ennis Town Council and Clare County Council is one of the highest of any town and county council in the country. If the charge was directly transferred at its current rate it would mean a 10 per cent increase in the charge levied for businesses in Ennis.

“The town council is going to set a rate in Ennis until June of next year and we don’t know what is going to happen in July. There is a huge disparity between the town council rate and the county council rate in Ennis, and the fear is that the new rate will be adjusted upwards. But businesses in Ennis could see a jump of something like 10 per cent next year,” said Rita McInerney, CEO of Ennis Chamber of Commerce.

“Our members could budget for the year on one rate and then come July that rate is no more. That is the fear that a lot of businesses in Ennis have right now.”

Following the news that 16 jobs could be jeopardy at the Gallery Cafe in Gort, Rita called for all local authorities to show more support for local businesses.

“It is difficult in the hospitality and tourism sector at the moment and everyone is looking at every way they cant increase revenue of to cut costs.

“Businesses have looked at all of their expenses – like rent or staff costs and they have been able to make some progress. However, when it comes to rates, it is not something that you can shop around with,” she said.

“That is the most frustrating thing for businesses, as the recession has hit and as things have gotten more difficult, they have been able to work with suppliers and workers – but there has been no reduction in rates.”

A NEW York woman who spat at a flight on attendant on a transatlantic flight has been ordered to pay a fine of € 500.

The captain of a Delta Airlines flight was forced to divert the plane to Shannon Airport last week after passenger Marianne Thatcher (30) became difficult and aggressive, Ennis District Court was told on Thursday.

Ms Thatcher, with an address at 1257 Park Avenue, Apartment 3, New York City, pleaded guilty to three charges arising out of a drink fuelled incident aboard a Delta Airlines flight in the early hours of August 1.

She pleaded guilty to engaging in behaviour likely to cause annoyance or offence to any person on board the aircraft; being intoxicated to such an extent that might endanger herself or persons on board; engaging in behaviour of threatening and or abusive nature with intent to provoke a breach of the peace.

All offences are contrary to the Air Navigation and Transport Act.

The court heard that Ms Thatcher came to the attention of flight attendants four hours into the flight from New York’s JKF Airport to Athens.

The court heard that Ms Thatcher was drinking wine and became abusive towards staff.

Inspector Tom Kennedy said flight attendants offered Ms Thatcher a glass of water and some food.

“Ms Thatcher reacted badly and effectively demanded more wine,” he added.

The court heard Ms Thatcher was brought to a vacant seat at the rear of the plane.

Insp Kennedy said she spat at a flight attendant after being asked to sit down. She was restrained using plastic handcuffs.

He added, “The State will say she was intoxicated. Her behaviour was very aggressive.”

He said the episode lasted 30 minutes.

A total of 270 passengers and 13 crew were on board at the time.

The court heard the captain made the decision to divert to Shannon when the plane was 250km off the Irish coast.

Ms Thatcher was met by gardai at Shannon Airport and placed into custody. She has no previous convictions.

The court heard Ms Thatcher, who holds dual American and Greek citizenship, comes from a respected family and studied liberal arts and ceramics in college.

She previously worked in a Paris art gallery but returned to New York to care for her sick father.

Defence solicitor Catriona Carmody said her client suffered from depression and developed problems with alcohol following her father’s death.

She said Ms Thatcher was “terrified” to be in court.

Ms Carmody said her client had a drink at the airport and a few more on the plane and doesn’t remember anything about the incident on the flight..

“She is incredibly embarrassed about what happened.

“She feels she has brought terrible shame on herself and her family,” Ms Carmody added.

Passing sentence, Judge Aeneas McCarthy said passengers had been very much inconvenienced by Ms Thatcher’s behaviour.

“This is a clearly a serious matter. This airplane had to be diverted,” he added.

He imposed a € 500 fine with one month to pay and 10 days in prison in default.

Ms Carmody said the fine would be paid within 24 hours.

Recognances were fixed in the event of an appeal.

CLARE’S Water Safety Officer has warned people to remain vigilant on the county’s beaches following the rescue of a family of four from a West Clare beach last weekend.

The entire family were rescued by lifeguards, including a father, mother and four children who got caught in a rip current.

Describing the incident as serious Liam Griffin said, “If the lifeguards had not got involved I shudder to think what the consequences might have been for the entire family.”

“We still have a long way to go until the end of the summer. We still have the full month of August. If we get another fine spell we just don’t want three further drowning in county Clare.

“The three we had in July are three too many as far as I am concerned,” he said.

“If we do get a return of the fine weather I hope that we won’t have further fatalities and people will swim in the guarded locations and not to be swimming in quarries, reservoirs, rivers and un-recommended areas, places where they were swimming during the last warm spell.”

Mr Griffin said that despite the downturn in temperatures the county’s beaches are still very busy.

He advised beach goers to go to guarded beaches and swim between the flags.

“If you do that you are going to be grand.

“You won’t have a problem but there are people who don’t do that. They swim away from where the swim zone is and when they get into difficulty we have to try to take immediate action,” he said.