Category: Uncategorized

AN 11-YEAR boy failed in his des- perate efforts to revive his four-year- old brother after finding him hang- ing by his hood from a toilet window at their primary school in east Clare last year.

At an inquest in Ennis last Tuesday into the death of junior infant, Karl Fox, a jury was told that his then 11- year-old brother, Gavin, climbed on top of a friend’s bicycle and lifted Karl from the window and on to the ground on March 14, 2006 at Feakle National School.

According to evidence from Garda Vivian Cahalane, “Gavin tried to wake up Karl, but failed to do so.”

Garda Cahalane said Gavin re- membered that “Karl was cold at that stage’. The inquest was told that Gavin put Karl over his shoulder and went onto the public road outside the school to get help.

Local | woman,

Mary Rose

Loughnane was bringing her daugh- ter from dance class and saw Gavin in a very distressed state and he called out “Help Miss’.

Ms Loughnane said that she no- ticed that Karl’s lips were blue and that he was unconscious. She drove the two home and on arriving at the Fox home, the boys’ mother, Linda came out “to take Karl from Gavin’s shoulder and tried to wake him by shaking him. She then became dis- tressed as he wasn’t responding.”

In her deposition, Linda said, “Karl was limp in my arms and I noticed that his lips were blue.”

She then ran to a neighbour’s house with Karl in her arms.

At the house, a student nurse at- tempted to revive Karl before an ambulance arrived to take the boy to Ennis General Hospital. How- ever, Karl was pronounced dead at 6.20pm.

The inquest was told that Gavin was at hurling training after school between 3pm and 4pm and had seen Karl playing around the field at 3.30pm.

Gavin returned home after train-

ing but Karl was not there and their mother Linda asked Gavin to return to find Karl “because I remember looking at my watch and thinking it was too late for Karl to be out”.

Feakle National School teacher, Marie Clune took hurling training on the day and in her statement said she remembered seeing Karl at around 4.05pm walking by himself in the school yard. She was asked to lock up the school as principal, Ted Har- rington had to go to the local bank.

She called out a couple of times to make sure that there was no one left in the school building before she locked up.

She said, “I didn’t get any response so I proceeded to close the door and lock it. When I drove away from the school, I was happy that there was nobody left on the school grounds.”

Garda John Cunningham – said when later examining the scene with Mr Harrington, “we visited the boys’ toilet and the window Karl had got

caught on was in the middle above the sinks”.

Garda Cunningham said that they also found a yellow infant’s chair and a brown chair also 1n the toilet under a window that was barred.

Assistant State Pathologist, Dr Michael Curtis said he found three very faint discontinuous bruises on Karl’s neck that were consistent with the application of a broad ligature, such as clothing. He concluded that the cause of death was accidental hanging.

County Coroner, Isobel O’Dea said Karl’s death was very tragic and very sad for his parents, his siblings, his school and the wider Feakle commu- nity. She said ‘accidental hanging’ was the appropriate verdict and after deliberating for a short time, the jury returned that verdict.

SECONDARY school students in Shannon have benefited from the de- livery of a personal and social devel- opment programme, which has been offered by the local youth service.

Youth workers Cathal Dillon and Thomas O’Hara have linked in with students at both St Caimin’s and St Patrick’s Comprehensive School in the town, in offering the pro- eramme.

The twelve-week programme 1s Open to non-examination year stu- dents, and runs for an hour, once a week.

In all, 20 young people from Shan- non will complete the programme,

which deals with topics including family, friends, authority, loneliness and communication.

The programme offers young peo- ple opportunities to discuss and ex- plore issues, that are important to them. It is carefully designed to assist the young people in their personal and social development, by discuss- ing topics of importance to them such as relationships, friendship and trust. This also helps them to enhance their communication skills and build their self-confidence.

On completion of the programme, the young people will receive certifi- cates at an assembly where parents are invited to go along and experi- ence a taste of the programme for

themselves and see the presentations designed by each group also.

Youth worker Cathal Dillon said the group is working well together and everyone is enjoying the pro- eramme.

“The group work together bound by a contract which they come up with with the tutor at the beginning. They share their experiences and thoughts on the topics at their own level. There is no pressure put on people. Over the weeks the group gel together and trust and friendship is built up and com- munication improves. This allows the eroup to feel comfortable and speak freely about topics such as friendship and loneliness, towards the end of the program. The group also get the op-

portunity to question two visitors to the group. The first visitor 1s a youth worker and the second someone who works with people who may be lone- ly. This gives them an opportunity to enhance their communication skills and see how they react to meeting new people,’ he said.

“The whole thing is enjoyable and interesting. I’ve got to know some of the people from my school much better. One thing I think everyone thinks is how the exercises put per- sonal life into a different perspective, which can be very informing. I think everyone enjoys it and I’m definitely glad I chose to try it,” said student Garry McKee, who is taking part in the project.

AN application has been lodged with Clare County Council to rezone al- most 100 acres at Barefield for hous- ing, commercial and community use.

The application for rezoning has been made by Benster Ltd and is one of the 168 submissions made to Clare County Council in relation to the review of the Ennis and Environs Development Plan.

However, 1n response to the propos-

al, the Council’s Planning Depart- ment has stated, “There is no iden- tified need to zone additional land residential to meet the future needs of the plan period”.

Separately, an application has been made by Crystal Partners to zone land at Gaurus outside Ennis for a local centre and rezone land from limited residential land or ‘other set- tlement land’ to residential.

The planner’s report states, ““The proposal for a local centre is within a larger site zoned residential, located

south of the Knockanean Road, in the eastern Residential Development Area.

“There are two local centres zoned in this area, one at Roslevan one kilometre to the north west, which is partly developed and one south of the Tulla Road approximately 400 metres to the north, which is not de- veloped.

“In reviewing the plan, account will be taken of the ability of the area to absorb a third local centre, the dis- tance between the local centres and

future population growth.”

As part of its plan for the area, Crystal Partners are in negotiation with Doora Barefield parish and in an update to parishioners state, “Crystal Partners developed land and own Roslevan shopping centre and also have development land at Gaurus.

“On these lands, they have offered to provide a site for a 16-teacher school, a pre-school facility and a hurling pitch as part of their develop- ment proposals for the area — this is subject to planning permission being

granted.”

The update continues that the de- velopers “will continue negotiations with our development group in re- lation to the provision of a church, community hall, children’s play- ground and all weather pitches on the Fahy Hall lands in exchange for part of our lands in this area.”

Discussion on the submissions is to take place between members of En- nis Town Council and Clare County Council in the first two weeks of May.

THE Deputy Mayor of Ennis has expressed his anger about the provi- sion of subsidised and free water to householders in Galway while local people have been paying for bottled water since a boil notice was intro- duced two years ago.

Councillor Brian Meaney (GP) be- lieves that the “political situation in Galway is what is driving the dif- ference in Government reaction be-

tween the two constituencies”.

‘There is a lot of anger at the differ- ence in treating the water consumers in Clare and Galway. The water crisis has been on going in Galway for the last six weeks. Why wasn’t subsidised water made available to the consum- ers of the Ennis supply six weeks into the crisis that has existed here for the last two years?” he asked.

A cautionary boil notice, affecting around 30,000 people, has been in place for the past two years in En-

nis, Clarecastle, Crusheen, Barefield, Doora, Drumcliffe, Spancilhill and Group Water Schemes on the supply.

Vulnerable sectors of the commu- nity, including patients with weak immune systems, infants and pre- school children, have been advised to continue to boil tap water before eyetsieueeyelaceyee

Previous contaminations of the En- nis water supply occurred after heavy rain following significant spells of dry weather just like in Galway.

Councillor Meaney accused the Government of total indifference on the issue and warned that Ennis could soon be in a similar situation to Galway.

“Despite the installation of a filtra- tion system, the boil notice has been in operation in Ennis and the sur- rounding area for the past two years. Cryptosporidium is already in the water supply and it may only be a matter of time before levels surge and an outbreak occurs like that which is

now affecting Galway,” he said.

The councillor added, “Confidence in the Ennis water supply is low and bottled water is expensive. It seems that this problem is of little conse- quence to the Government, unless the problem becomes so bad that it may cost them votes.

“A lack of infrastructure and a fail- ure to update a dated water supply that leaks millions of litres of water a day, has led to the situation we find ourselves in today.”

SUNDAY’S road fatalities once again highlighted the number of road deaths occurring in the west Clare area. Tragically, the deaths of Eoin Glynn and Shane Donnellan bring to six the number of people killed in road ac- cidents in Clare since the start of the year. Four of the six deaths occurred on west Clare roads. Add this to the

fact that five of the county’s nine road casualties last year occurred in west Clare and the picture is particularly bleak. Nine road deaths in one area of the county over a 12-month period are far more than should be faced by local CLoyenvenlereple lee

The carnage is spread throughout the area. Communities in Lissycasey, Doonbeg, Kilrush, Kildysart, Killimer and Kilkee have mourned losses due to

road fatalities over the past 12 months.

Ironically, Sunday’s smash came al- most a year to the day since Sean Gal- lagher (71) was killed after he got out of his car at the Boree Log in Lissy- casey. That accident occurred on Mon- day, April 17, 2006.

A young Dublin man, Stephen O’Reilly (24), was killed in Kilkee in the early hours of January 29, while pensioner Tom Haugh (69) died as a

result of an accident in which his car was involved in a collision at Carrow- dotia, Killimer, on March 27.

The roads in west Clare are not alien to particularly harrowing cases of mul- tiple road fatalities. In October 2003, the community of Carrigaholt was forced to come to terms with the deaths of two young girls, Stacey Haugh (16) and Lorna O’Mahony (13). The girls died instantly when the car a young

Galway man was driving crashed into a wall, at Moyarta, on the road between Kilkee and Carrigaholt.

Tragedy on the double also struck in May 2005, when an accident in Quilty claimed the lives of Thomas Pender and David McCarthy (18). The car Mr Jo ele(o um eRO NU AAU OToam OUI Mrs Mats: 00 mm DOME HET e early hours of the morning. Mr Mc- Carthy, of Seafield, Quilty, was a front Seat passenger.

MARGUERITE O’Dwyer was ly- ing on the couch, smiling, when her brother approached her with a ham- mer and repeatedly attacked her.

Patrick O’Dwyer told gardai that the two were watching television on Monday evening, November 29, 2004, when he left the sitting room to go into the kitchen.

“At about 11.30pm, I just remem- bered going out to the kitchen. I took the hammer out of the press. Marguerite was lying on the couch. She was smiling at me. She thought I was messing. I would often be messing with her with a hurley and things. I swung the hammer and hit

her on the head five or six times. I hit her on the chest,” he told gardai. He said his sister wasn’t scream- ing. She was alive. He then got a knife from the kitchen and a Scis- sors from the bathroom and started jabbing her to the ribs and legs. At that stage she was on the ground.

He later went down town, before returning to the house and drinking a half can of beer. He went upstairs and stuck a blade into a vein on his left wrist and hit himself to the head a few times with a hammer.

He brought firelighters upstairs and considered setting fire to the house.

He said he did not realise the sig- nificance of what he had done until

the following day when he touched his sister and her head was cold. He then went to Ennistymon garda sta- BLOyEE

He said he originally got the ham- mer to hit himself as he felt he had made “a fool” out of himself the previous Saturday night, by drink- ing excessively.

The court heard that when the ac- cused arrived at Ennistymon garda station on the afternoon of Novem- ber 30, he showed a garda a cut to his head and mark to his wrist. The garda noted that he had a mark on his nose.

Garda Alan Keane went to O’Dwyer’s home, where he found the young woman’s body in the sit-

ting room.

He said there was a considerable amount of blood on the floor and the woman was lying down, face up.

A white blanket covered her legs and there was no sign of a pulse.

Under cross-examination by the accused’s barrister, Patrick Gage- by, SC, the garda admitted that the scene was “shocking”.

Sergeant Brian Howard told the tri- al that, after the accused arrived at the local garda station, gardai were concerned about his health. He was taken to Ennis General Hospital.

A senior psychiatrist assessed him and concluded he “had not psychiat- ric problems and was not a danger to himself”.

FIVE hundred and fifty workers at Shannon airport have until next Monday to decide whether they wish to accept a voluntary redundancy deal at the airport.

Letters sent out to workers by the Shannon Airport Authority (SAA) stated that the workers had until April 23 to sign “an irrevocable agreement of exit” if they wish to take the redundancy deal.

In order for the €36 million sur-

vival plan to work, the SAA requires 200 workers or more to leave.

Information sessions on pensions and the tax implications for indi- viduals will continue at the airport WDA (e1o).@

Those with 24 or more years of ex- perience who opt to leave the SAA will receive over €100,000 while the 350 workers who remain will receive a payment of €16,000.

The deal is expected to save the SAA €10 million per annum.

In the new revamped Shannon air- port, international retail organisa-

tion HMS Host has secured the con- tract to operate five retail outlets at Shannon.

The company already serves 70 airports around the world, including Cork airport.

The arrival of HMS Host into Shan- non also increases the chances of Shannon having the first Starbucks coffee shop 1n county Clare.

A Starbucks operating under li- cense from HMS Host opened in Cork airport last year. Most of the Irish outlets of the popular Ameri- can coffee chain are in Dublin.

HMS Host has already advertised for senior managerial positions in- cluding Business Controller, Finan- cial Administrator, Food and Bev- erage Manager and is hoping to be trading in Shannon airport this com- ing summer.

The deal for a restructured Shan- non earlier this month secured the overwhelming endorsement of the unions at the airport where 84% of SIPTU voted in favour of the plan.

Talks on the deal commenced al- most two years ago and the slow progress has prevented the Shannon

Airport Authority (SAA) from lodg- ing a business plan with Government in order to become an independent entity.

In January, workers at Shannon overwhelmingly voted down a pre- vious survival plan valued at €34 million.

However, marathon negotiations under the auspices of the Labour Relations Commission (LRC) last month at the airport resulted in the SAA agreeing to provide an addi- tional €2 million to a revised sur- ane Nm) E- bee

SK YCOURT management has decid- ed to defer planned parking charges, which had been expected to be re- introduced in July.

The announcement is the latest move on the ongoing twist into pay parking. Barriers were placed at the entrance to the surface carpark last year. Following representations by local traders – who argued that they were an inconvenience to shoppers – these barriers were removed last Oc- tober. SkyCourt management pointed out at the time that parking for the first two hours would continue to be free of charge, until July 1.

However, SkyCourt has now stated that parking charges for the first two hours has been deferred and Sky- Court is working on significant plans which will improve shopping choice ANNO MIE DUCA

“Until such time as these develop- ments are advanced further, we have decided to defer the introduction of the planned parking charges on July Ist,’ said SkyCourt Manager, Pat ea

The existing pay-and-display system will continue to operate. The first two hours are free, in both the surface and multi-storey car parks. Customers who park for longer than two hours will continue to be liable for a charge

of <1 per hour. Meanwhile, SkyCourt has _§an- nounced that three new businesses will open at the shopping mall. Two of the three are restaurants and the third is a traditional Chinese medi- cine shop, Herbmedic, which has just opened its doors. The restaurants are Apache pizza and the Royal Dorbar Indian restau- rant. Apache will open in mid-May, and will employ eight people, while the Indian restaurant will open in June, also with a staff of eight. Mr Kelly said that the shopping cen- tre is currently engaged in negotia- tions regarding other shops and out- lets and he expects a number of other significant announcements shortly. The franchisee of Apache is Paki- stan-born Jimmy Ajmal who came to Ireland in [997 to study at the Shan- non School of Hotel Management. When he graduated in 2001, he joined the hotel industry and worked for five years with the Lynch Hotel Group at Breatfy House Hotel in Castlebar and the West County Hotel in Ennis. The 50-seat Royal Dorbar restau- rant will specialise in Indian ethnic foods. Director Anowar Haq Iqbal already operates a very successful sister restaurant at the Cornmarket in Limerick. It will be located upstairs between Supermacs and Shannon Gahan

THE issue of diminished respon- sibility 1s a central part of the case and it will be up to the jury to decide if Patrick O’Dwyer suffered from a mental disorder when he killed his sister, according to the prosecution. Outlining the facts of the case, sen- ior counsel for the prosecution, John Edwards told the jury of six men and six women that Marguerite O’ Dwyer was a 17-year-old Leaving Certifi- cate student at the Convent of Mercy, Ennistymon, and her brother Patrick was a 19-year-old apprentice butcher

in the town.

The two were staying on their own in the family home at Shrohill, En- nistymon, on November 29, 2004.

Their sister Louise was in Galway — where she was a university student — and their parents were on a week- long holiday in Gran Canaria.

Mr Edwards said that at 2.40pm on November 30, Patrick O’ Dwyer walked into Ennistymon garda sta- tion and said he had killed his sister.

Mr Edwards said gardai went to the O’Dwyer home and found a body in the sitting room.

State Pathologist Dr Marie Cas-

sidy carried out a post-mortem ex- amination on the deceased’s body and found she died from blunt force trauma to the head, as a result of six blows.

“This type of injury would cause rapid death and it was irrecoverable,” he said.

He said Marguerite had sustained at least 90 stab wounds to the head, trunk, legs and body. Many of the wounds were sustained after the young girl had been immobilised and possibly dead.

Mr Edwards said the accused ad- mitted causing the injuries from

which his sister died.

‘Marguerite O’Dwyer was hit over the head viciously with a hammer on a number of occasions. Stab wounds were perpetrated on her body with a scissors. There were 90 odd stab wounds. It’s the State’s case that if you hit somebody over the head re- peatedly with a hammer, the natural probable consequences of that is that you are going to kill the person or seriously injure. It’s the State’s case that Patrick O’ Dwyer intended to kill her,’ he said.

“You may hear evidence that will seek to rebut that. It 1s the prosecu- tion’s case that this was murder and nothing else. What is likely to be a central issue in this case 1s whether or not the accused was a person of diminished responsibility. Up until recently, there was no case in Irish law of diminished responsibility. If a defence of diminished responsibil- ity is canvassed, that will be a matter for you to consider. I understand that it will be canvassed. You have to be satisfied that Patrick O’Dwyer com- mitted the act alleged and you have to be satisfied at the time he suffered from a mental disorder.”

“The issue for you is to decide whether this is a crime of murder or a crime of manslaughter,” said Mr Edwards.

A MAJOR new tourism plan for the Shannon Region is to be unveiled later this month. Shannon Develop- ment, the regional tourism authority will unveil its new tourism market- ing plans at a seminar it 1s hosting for members of the Shannon region tour- ism industry.

The seminar will be held at the South Court Hotel, Limerick on Thursday, April 26.

“The performance of the tourism sector 1n 2006 has been good and we want to build on this in 2007 and the coming years and let the industry know our exciting new plans,” said John King, Heritage and Tourism D1- rector, Shannon Development.

Shannon Development is due to an- nounce its detailed 2007-2008 region- al tourism plans at the seminar. The plan will highlight key challenges facing global tourism and how that will impact on the tourism industry in the Shannon region. Part of the pres- entation will involve an overview of the plans for the promotion and devel- opment of the industry by Shannon Development Tourism over the com- ing year.

Shaun Quinn, CEO Failte Ireland and Paul O’ Toole, CEO Tourism Ire- land will also give detailed presenta- tions covering the key activities of both agencies for 2007. In addition to the key note speakers, the main execu- tives from all agencies will be present at the events to discuss specific issues

such as training, international promo- tion, and product development. The seminar is free and open to all. Reg- istration for the event is at 9.00am for a 9.30am start and will continue until lpm.

Commenting on the seminar, John King, Heritage and Tourism Director, Shannon Development, said “Tourism is now the largest indigenous Irish In- dustry, accounting for over €450 mil- lion of direct tourism expenditure in this region alone, and will be central to the future economic development of the west. I would strongly encour- age tourism industry members to at- tend this event to get a full briefing on the activities of the tourism agencies, and use the forum to raise issues spe- cific to their business or sector.”