Category: News

JAIL terms have been handed down to two people involved in a violent Halloween home invasion in Ennis three years ago.

Carrie Brigdale (23) and Sean Moroney (41) were both sentenced to two years in prison for their roles in a alcohol fueled violent disorder incident that occurred at a rented apartment in Ennis on October 31 (2010).

Ugandan national Collins Kato (28) suffered multiple stab wounds during the assault at 13 Parnell Court.

He was also robbed of € 1640, two laptops and iPhone when a group of 10 people entered his home for a Halloween night party.

Seven people charged in connection with the incident, appeared before Judge Caroll Moran yesterday for sentence.

Judge Moran said Mr Kato had been subjected to a four and a half hour ordeal, during which he was restrained, kicked, robbed and stabbed in the neck with broken shards of a mirror.

He added, “This was an appalling incident, an incident that clearly got out of hand because of the influence of drink.”

The court heard Mr Kato asked the group to leave because of noise concerns and after he found three of them in a “sexually compromising position” in a bedroom.

Gardaí found Mr Kato “coming in and out of consciousness” when they arrived at the scene.

In his victim impact statement, heard in April, Mr Kato said he suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder and feels “lucky to be alive.”

Judge Moran said evidence had been given that mother of three Ms Brigdale was heard to make a “terrifying threat” of “if this guy lives we’re in trouble”.

After which, Judge Moran said, another person said, “cut his throat.”

Judge Moran said Ms Brigdale, with a former address of Mill House Flats, Mill Road, Ennis and currently of no fixed abode, was the most culpable of the group.

She received a two-year sentence after pleading guilty to violent disorder, assault causing harm and production of an article during the course of a dispute.

Mr Moroney, with an address at 31 Dalcassian Park, hit Mr Kato over the heard with a fire extinguisher. He received a two-year sentence for violent disorder. He has 34 previous convictions.

Four other people also appeared before the court.

Caroline Lyons (22), with an address at 15 Waterpark Heights, pleaded guilty to violent disorder. Judge Moran said Ms Lyons, who has 17 previous convictions, invited people to the apartment after initially coming on the night to view the premises to rent.

She received a two year suspended sentence on condition she abstain from alcohol and be of good behaviour.

Her brother Gerard Lyons (21), with an address at 15 Waterpark Heights, Ennis pleaded guilty to violent disorder. He also received a two year suspended sentence.

Warren O’Donnell (21), with an address at Laurel Lodge, Ennis and Moore Street, Kilrush, pleaded guilty to violent disorder. Judge Moran said O’Donnell admitted being one of the people in the “sexually compromising position” and being present when Mr Kato was assaulted. He received a two-year sentence.

A mother of one who was 17 at the time of incident pleaded guilty to violent disorder. She received the probation act.

A 19 year old man who was 16 at the time of incident pleaded guilty to stealing € 1640.

The court heard yesterday that he has re-paid € 800.

Judge Moran said he would suspend a two-year sentence if the man re-paid the rest of the money by July 22.

Two other men were also charged in connection with the incident. The court heard yesterday that one of those has since died and the other man is no longer thought to be in the jurisdiction.

THE CLARE toddler that was waiting five hours to have a head wound treated at the University Hospital Limerick, was treated within a time fame that is not only acceptable but strived for by the HSE.

In relation to queries from

A SKULL discovered in Quin almost five years ago may have belonged to a compulsive pipe smoking woman, who died in her 40’s more than 300 years ago.

The human remains, which were discovered in Quin in August of 2008, have been shrouded in mystery for the last five years. However, research carried out by TVAS Ireland, who discovered the remains, had shed some light on the historic discovery.

While many questions remain unanswered, the possible life story of the Quin body has started to emerge.

“We now know that the jaw bone had typical female traits – so we can cautiously say that the body was a female.

“We know that the person also suffered from arthritis – part of the bones discovered were from the spine and there was evidence of the bones rubbing together.

“So we are fairly sure that the person would have had severe neck pain,” said Edel Ruttle of TVAS.

“From the jaw bone we noticed a third molar – or wisdom tooth. So we are confident that the body was aged somewhere between 21 and 40 years of age. Interestingly, we also saw a clay pipe semi-circle on the body’s teeth, this is consistent to a person holding a clay pipe in her mouth almost constantly.

“So not only was this person a smoker – they would have had to hold the clay pipe in their mouth for hours and hours every day to make marks consistent with the ones we have discovered.”

Despite these discoveries, it is still unclear why the body was buried in that spot and what religious the woman was.

One theory maintains that the woman was a social outcast of some sort, which is why she was buried on the edge of a disused Catholic grave – and not in the regular Catholic or Protestant graveyards which were in use in Quin at that time.

“She is buried in an East/West lie – which suggest that it was, at least, a partially standard burial, but the she is buried on the very edge of the cemetery – probably after the cemetery went out of use. So it’s difficult to know,”continued Edel.

“It is possible that she was a marginal figure.

“Maybe she wasn’t buried in the graveyard in Quin Friary because of some social standing – or lack of social standing.

“These are possibilities, but we don’t know for sure. There is still a lot of mystery surrounding this body.”

IT COULD be full steam ahead for the old West Clare Railway line as the Government provide € 50,000 for a West Clare Railway Greenway project.

Not only have new plans been lodged with Clare County Council to extend the popular west Clare Railway in Moyasta but according to Labour TD Michael McNamara Minister for Public Transport, is to provide the € 50,000 seed funding to kick-start the Green Way Project.

He said the Westport to Achill Greenway in Mayo has been an outstanding success and contributes over € 1 million to the local economy each year.

“The history, folklore and song associated with the West Clare Railway greatly enhances the attractiveness of a walking/cycling Greenway along the historic route.

“The grant of € 50,000 will be used by Clare County Council for design and planning purposes.

“I am totally committed to the project and will do all that I can to secure the major capital funding which the project will require,” said Deputy McNamara.

The proposed West Clare Railway Greenway when completed will link Ennis with Lahinch. Its total length will be 40km but will be delivered as a four phase project. The final phase of 3.5km linking Ennistymon with Lahinch has already been completed.

The remaining four phases are: Ennis to Ballymaquiggan (3.9km), Ballymaquiggan to Corofin (15km) and Corofin to Ennistymon (18km).

Meanwhile plans have been filed with Clare County Council to extend the West Clare Railway.

The plan includes 1,853 square National Railway Heritage Museum that will include a café and toilets, at the station that inspired the Percy French song “ Are You Right There Michael? ”

The application also includes a rail way and pedestrian crossing on the N67 Kilrush to Kilkee road, as well as pathway footbridge and associated site works.

Clare County Council granted planning permission to a similar project in 2009 but the National Roads Authority successfully appealed the decision to An Bord Pleanala.

The new development included rail and pedestrian crossings along the N67, whose sped limit has since been reduced from 100 kilometres per hour to 60 kilometres per hour.

FIFTY years to the week that President John F Kennedy said farewell to Ireland at Shannon Airport with his famous pledge to “come back and see old Shannon’s face again”, it has been claimed that his wife Jackie Kennedy Irish ancestors hailed from West Clare. American genealogist Jim O’Callaghan has claimed that Jackie Kennedy was more Irish than her husband, saying that she was “one-eighth French amost of her ancestors coming from Shandrum, near Mullagh, in Co Clare”.

O’Callaghan discovered that on her maternal line, all eight greatgreat grandparents and two of her four great-grandparents were born in Ireland, making her more Mullagh than Montpellier. John F Kennedy also had Clare roots, with his great grandfather being James Hickey who hailed from near Dromoland Castle.

A JURY has begun deliberating in the trial of a Clare farmer, Joe Heffernan , charged with murdering a 21-year-old student on his land two years ago.

Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy yesterday (Monday) told the seven women and five men of the jury that they could reach one of three possible verdicts, none of which could be an acquittal.

Meanwhile the trial of Colm Deely (41), who is accused of murdering Deirdre McCarthy was adjourned for a number of days last week. It resumes this morning (Tuesday).

It is expected to have concluded by the end of this week.

A forensic psychiatrist told the Heffernan trial that the accused (33) knew what he was doing was wrong when he killed a student, whom he said was the devil. Dr Sally Linehan of the Central Mental Hospital was giving evidence to the Central Criminal Court in the trial of the farmer charged with murdering the 21-year-old on his farm.

Dr Linehan testified last Wednesday that she had interviewed Mr Heffernan three times since the incident and had studied his records from his time in the Central Mental Hospital following his arrest. The trial also heard harrowing testimony from two friends who were with Eoin Ryan on the night he died.

A HOMELESSNESS campaigner convicted of stealing almost € 27,000 from a pensioner in Ennis will represent herself at a sentencing hearing next month, a court has heard.

Ennis woman Josephine O’Brien (59) told Ennis Circuit Criminal court last week that she had “dismissed” her legal team.

In April, Ms O’Brien, with an address at 15 Bridgeview, Roslevan, was convicted by a jury of nine of 10 counts of theft from the bank account of Stephen O’Halloran (87), a resident of St Joseph’s nursing home.

Ms O’Brien, a founder of the Homeless Education Learning Programme (HELP), was found guilty of stealing € 26, 503 on dates between July 2006 and October 2010.

The court heard she used some of the money to open a homeless shelter in Chapel Lane.

The case was listed for sentence at Ennis Circuit Criminal Court last week. On Tuesday, Defence Solicitor Daragh Hassett applied to come off record in the case.

He said Defence Counsel, Lorcan Connolly BL, was also coming off record.

Mr Hassett told the court he had “strongly advised “Ms O’Brien that she should have legal representation for sentencing.

Ms O’Brien confirmed in court to Judge Keyes that she wished to represent herself.

She added, “I’m an intelligent woman and I’m quite capable of representing myself.”

Judge Gerard Keyes said, “That is your choice and we will respect it.”

Ms O’Brien told the court she sent an affidavit to the Attorney General.

Judge Keyes told Ms O’Brien that she had been found guilty on a number of counts after a trial.

In reply, Ms O’Brien said, “I have been found guilty on facts but there was no crime.”

Judge Keyes advised Ms O’Brien that she must go through the process of sentencing.

He told Ms O’Brien that the option to appeal was open to her after sentencing is complete, if she wished to pursue it.

Ms O’Brien also indicated to the court that she wished to get the tapes of her garda interviews.

Judge Keyes said Ms O’Brien must first make an application to the court. He added that the tapes would be released “subject to strict conditions.”

Sentencing was adjourned to July 11. Ms O’Brien is on continuing bail.

PROGRESS has been made in attempts to secure accommodation for a wheelchair bound man who set fire to a nursing home in Killaloe, a court has heard.

In February, James Sherlock Jnr, formerly of 16 Childers Road, Cloughleigh, Ennis pleaded guilty at Ennis Circuit Criminal Court to causing arson at the Lakes Nursing Home in Killaloe on August 20 (2010).

The 24 year old is confined to a wheelchair after loosing both of his legs to amputation.

Heroin addiction lead to the amputation of Mr Sherlock’s right leg. He recently underwent surgery to amputate his left leg.

Finalisation of the case had been adjourned pending suitable accommodation being found for Mr Sherlock.

Circuit Court Judge, Gerard Keyes has said the State must find suit- able facilities for Mr Sherlock. Judge Keyes has previously indicated that he will not impose a custodial sentence. The Court was previously told that due to Mr Sherlock’s past behavioral difficulties and his pleading guilty to arson, many nursing homes and hostels would not accept him due to insurance issues.

The court has heard that discussions have taken place between local authorities, The Probation Services and the Health Services Executive (HSE) with the aim of finding accommodation for Mr Sherlock.

The case came back before the court on Tuesday. Counsel for Mr Sherlock, Pat Whyms BL told the court that the local authority has made progress in attempts to find accommodation for his client.

He said the Probation Service were seeking a further adjournment of the case.

Judge Keyes said he was not going to “interfere” with the progress being made.

Mr Sherlock has spent a period of time staying at the vacant Fairways apartment block in Ennis.

A TOTAL of 304 people presented as homeless last year in Clare according to the county’s draft homelessness plan

More women (160) than men presented as homeless with the majority of people (122) aged between 20 and 29.

A total of 19 people under the age of 19 and 10 persons aged 60+ presented as homeless in 2012.

Most of those presented (212) said Clare was their county of origin.

The next highest number of people came from Limerick (27). Non European Union homeless people accounted for 12 with three coming from EU countries.

12 people from accession state countries presented as homeless in 2012.

83 people found themselves homeless due to domestic violence; 52 due to breakdown of an independent living arrangement; 34 people pre- sented as transient; 20 people were evicted from private accommodation and 18 people presenting as homeless had been released from prison.

According to the figures four people were discharged from acute hospital; three were discharged from a treatment centre and one person was homeless due to alcohol and drug addiction.

Cllr Mary Howard (FG) told the June meeting of Ennis Town Council that young mothers and children are now becoming homeless.

She added, “That’s what I find heartbreaking about this, the stories behind the figures. This isn’t partying kids.” Cllr Howard was speaking in response to earlier comments from Cllr Michael Guilfoyle (Ind) who claimed that some homeless people who secure housing through agencies could be the source of antisocial behaviour in housing estates.

“There is often no follow up (by these agencies) in the estates,” he added.

Cllr Frankie Neylon (Ind) said that while it is “unfortunate” to see people drinking in laneways, homeless people “seem able to get housing more than our local people.”

“There are people using this homeless thing, especially in Ennis where the problem isn’t as big as that,” he added.

Cllr Paul O’Shea (Ind) said he found the figure of one person being homeless due to alcohol and drugs as “disingenuous.” He also claimed that the number of young people affected by homelessness is growing.

A BUSLOAD of tourists were sent on an extensive tour of West Clare which would not be an issue if that was their original intention.

However at the time the bus driver was attempting to drive the less than impressed passengers directly from Mullagh to Kilimer in time for the ferry, but poor road signage sent him on a tour through Doonbeg, Bellaha and into Kilkee before making the journey back to Killimer. Needless to say the tourists did not make their intended crossing on schedule and were delayed reaching Kerry as a result.

Kilrush Town Councillor Tom Prendeville (FF) said it was time for the council to follow through on a promise to upgrade signage, especially on approach roads to the town of Kilrush.

As a result of the 35 kilometre detour an appointment to have food in Kilrush also had to be cancelled.

“That was lost business to Kilrush,” said the local councillor.

“I am all for promoting West Clare and keeping tourists as long as possible in the area to sample the many attractions we have here.

“Signage should certainly offer tourists alternative destinations, but in this instance it was misguided and deceptive.

“That can be a great source of annoyance and irritation for some visitors on a tight schedule,” he said.

There is some hope for disgruntled bus drivers and bemused tourists however as Síobhan Garvey, Marketing and Development Officer in Kilrush said that the National Roads Authority is currently re-signing the national secondary N67 route from Miltown Malbay to Kilimer.

This will include the Kilkee Kilimer approach roads.

“As part of the process that will also be removing unlicensed roadside signage. The installation of their new signage scheme will provide clear directional guidance to the visiting motoring public and will include some tourist signage,” she said.

The marketing officer recognised that signage has been an issue in the area.

“There are plans to look in more detail at the Ennis approach road as a starting point by the Tidy Towns Liason Committee in the coming months.

“However both the Town Council and Tidy Town Committee are conscious that the NRA have not completed their signage project on the N67 and would like to see the outcome of this project so a clear plan can be put in place to deal with what signage needs to stay or be removed from the other approach roads in order to provide some unity to the entry – exit points of the town,” she said.